WHERE IGNORANCE IS BLISS ’TIS FOLLY TO BE
WISE
ITHE most delightful thing about our engagement is that
everybody is so pleased with it.” Amy Townsend said this, smiling
down at her lover, who, full length on the grass beside her, leaned
on his elbow, watching her soft hair blowing across her forehead,
and the color of the sun flickering through the shadows, hot on her
cheek; for she had closed her fluffy white parasol and taken off
her hat here under an oak-tree on the grassy bank of the
river.
“I should have thought that the fact that we were pleased
ourselves was a trifle more important,” he suggested. But Miss
Townsend paid no attention to his interruption.
“You know, generally, when people get engaged, there are
always people who exclaim: either the man is too good for the girl
(and you are too good for me, Billy!), or the girl is too good for
the man”—
“She is; there is no question about that,” the man
interrupted.
“Be quiet!” the other commanded. “But in our case, everybody
approves. You see, in the first place, you are a Parson, and I’m a
Worker. That’s what they call me,—the old ladies,—‘a Worker.’ And
of course that’s a most appropriate combination to start
with.”
“Well, the old ladies will discover that my wife isn’t going
to run their committees for them,” the parson said emphatically.
“Besides, if I’m a Parson, you’re a Person! How do the old ladies
bear it, that I haven’t any ancestors, and used to run errands in a
tin-shop?I’m a Worker,
literally enough.”
“You are a goose!” she told him calmly. “Don’t keep
interrupting me, Billy. What do ancestors amount to? I admit I’m
glad that none of mine were hanged (so far as I know), or that they
didn’t run off with other people’s money—or wives. (I’d mind the
wives less than the money, I must confess. I suppose you think
that’s very mediæval in me?) But what credit is their good behavior
to me? You are a credit to your people, whoever they were; and my
own belief is that they were Princes!”She had such a charming way of flinging up her head and
looking down at him sidewise, that he was willing to have had any
kind of ancestors, only to catch that look of joyous pride; and in
his own joyousness he was impelled to try to take her hand in his:
but her fingers were laced about her knee, and she shook her
head.
“Stop! I’m talking seriously; you mustn’t be silly. You must
listen to the other reasons why we are approved of: First, you are
a Parson, and I’m a Worker. Secondly, you are forty-two, and ‘it’s
high time’—high time, sir!—‘for you to be married’; and I’m
twenty-seven—and, really, you know, ‘my chances are
lessening’—(that’s what they say, my dear); and I ‘hardly deserve,
after all these years’”—
“And offers?” suggested her lover.
“After all theseyears,
Billy,—not to get a crooked stick in the end.”
“I am not crooked, I will admit,” he said.
“Thirdly,” she proceeded, “you are very good-looking, and all
the old Tabbies say that a handsome minister ought to be
married.”
“The old Tabbies might find something better to talk about,”
he said, his face hardening. “Oh, Amy, that’s the kind of thing
that makes a man cringe!—I mean a minister. Here is this great,
serious, strenuous matter of living—the consciousness of God;
that’s what living is in its highest expression. And to further
that consciousness is the divinest human passion. A man tries to do
it, gives his life to it, and immediately he is food for chattering
old women! They gossip about his affairs, or his clothes, or his
looks, even!” William West sat up, his face stirred with anger and
pity. “But I suppose I must admit that the Parsons bring it on
themselves to some extent,” he ended, with a sigh; “we don’t mingle
enough with men; they distrust us, and think we talk twaddle about
overcoming temptations we know nothing about. So, being shut out
from masculine living, we do haunt tea-tables, and gabble about
vestments. I suppose there’s no doubt of it. Amy, I believe that
the old hunting, swearing parsons of three generations ago were of
more real value in the world than the harmless creatures that we
have now!”He had a certain stern way of thrusting out his lower lip
when he was very much in earnest, and drawing his strong brows
together; an impatient fire sprang into his beautiful dark eyes. He
turned and looked at her, claiming her understanding.
“Yes,” she said; “yes, it is so. The belittling of the
profession of the ministry is a dreadful thing—a shameful thing. I
once heard a man say that ‘Elderly unmarried women always had to
have something to fuss over and coddle, something to lead around by
a blue ribbon. Sometimes it was a poodle; sometimes it was a
clergyman.’ And there’s truth in it, Billy.”
“There is,” he said grimly.
“Well, dear,” she reassured him, smiling, “your distinguished
rudeness to the ladies of your congregation has at least protected
you from the blue ribbon.”He began to protest, but the talk slipped back into their own
affairs, and somehow he succeeded in getting her hand, and by and
by they were silent, just for happiness, and because it was sunset,
and the river was flickering with light, and there was a faint stir
of leaves overhead. They were to be married in a fortnight, and
they were going to have all their lives together to say how good
life was, so there was no need to talk now.As the girl had said, it really was a very satisfactory
match. William West was a man whom every one honored, and many
loved. For fifteen years he had been settled in Mercer; first as an
assistant to old Mr. Brown, and then as rector of the church. But
he had taken his place in the community as a man of strong judgment
and high character; perhaps as a citizen, rather than as a
minister. Men felt that he was a man before he was a clergyman; not
knowing that his calling had given him his highest manhood. He was
singularly devoid of clerical affectation; consequently the
influence of his own reverence was not vitiated by a suspicion of
his common sense. In fact, his sanity in matters religious, joined
to his knowledge of human nature, made him a man of importance in
affairs municipal and social. That he had lived to be forty-two,
and had not married, was from no asceticism; he was a very human
person, and fully intended to have a wife; only, she must be just
what he wanted. And so far, that “not impossible She” who was to
possess his heart had never appeared. When she did, he recognized
her immediately, and would have proposed to her the next day, had
not a feeling of diffidence as to her sentiments deterred him for
nearly two weeks. At the end of that time, he told her—ah, well,
never mind what he told her! She, at least, will never forget the
passion of that claiming.Amy Townsend had come to spend the winter in Mercer, with a
cousin. Of course, the first Sunday she went to St. James’s, as
everybody who was anybody did. When she came home, her eyes were
keen with interest.
“Do tell me about him, Cousin Kate,” she said. “I never heard
that sort of preaching; what does it mean? Is he a real person, or
is he just clever?” Mrs. Paul laughed.
“Wait till you meet him! you’ll see.”But she also added to herself, “Wait till he meets you!” For
Mrs. Paul was one of those courageous women who rush in where
angels fear to tread; she was a match-maker.
“Is he married?” the girl asked, naturally enough; but
blushed furiously the next instant, which made her
angry.
“No; but it is not for lack of opportunity,” said Mrs. Paul
dryly. “I declare, Amy, women are dreadful fools, sometimes! I
should think a clergyman wouldn’t marry, out of sheer disgust for
their silliness.”
“Oh, he’s run after, is he?” Miss Townsend said
coldly.
“Well, I must admit he’s very attractive,” Mrs. Paul began,
remembering her scheme, and retreating a little,—for nothing will
put a girl against a man sooner than to know he is “run
after.”Then she told his story: the boy had been a waif. (“His
mother was respectable, I think,” said Mrs. Paul, “but nobody knows
anything about the father.”) He had had that dreariest sort of
childhood which knows no other home than an institution. Then,
somehow, “quite like a story-book,” Mrs. Paul said, a gentleman
took an interest in him, and began to help him in one way or
another.
“It was that zoölogical man, Professor Wilson; you know who I
mean?” Mrs. Paul explained. “He looked after him. At first he put
him in a tinshop, if you please, as errand-boy,—fancy! this man
with the ‘grand manner.’”
“Oh, I supposed he was a gentleman,” Amy Townsend
said.
“Amy, you are a snob,” her cousin answered hotly. “He
is.”Mrs. Paul was so annoyed that she ended the story of Mr.
West’s career very briefly. “Professor Wilson offered either to
start him in business or put him through college; he chose to go to
college.”
“That was rather fine,” Miss Townsend agreed.
“Fine? It just showed what sort of a man he was!” cried Mrs.
Paul. “He worked his way to some extent; that is, he was Professor
Wilson’s secretary, and he did a lot of tutoring. Professor Wilson
left him a good deal of money, but he gave away nearly half of it
at once, John says. Quite remarkable for a young man. Well, that’s
all; you see what he is to-day—a gentleman and a scholar: John says
there is no man in Mercer who has the influence that he
has.”Miss Townsend, in spite of her careful indifference, was
interested. And later, when Rev. William West met her, he, too, was
“interested;” and all fell out as the most experienced romancer
could desire.Amy had a little money, much charm, a certain distinction
that answered for beauty, and a very true nature; there was,
perhaps, a certain hard integrity about her, but her impulses were
gracious. Also, as the old ladies said, she was a “worker.” She
found life too interesting not to meddle with it.So it had come to pass that these two, who, as Mrs. Paul
said, “were made for each other,” were going to be
married.
“Just think, in two weeks!” he said, as they sat there under
the oak, the blossoming grass knee-deep about them, and the air
sweet with clover. “Amy, it does not seem as if I had been alive
until now.”
“I wonder, does it go on getting—nicer?” she asked him, a
little shyly; “everything seems to be better, and more worth
while.”
“I understand,” he said.And they were silent for awhile, because understanding is
enough, when people are in love. Then the girl’s gayety began to
sparkle out.
“Billy, Cousin Kate says if I’m not careful I’ll get to be a
managing Parsoness; she says I must devote myself to you, not to
your poor people.”
“Mrs. Paul has given a great deal of good advice in her day,”
the Rev. Billy remarked meditatively, “and I really think very
little harm has come from it.”
“She advised your being called to Mercer,” Amy retorted. “Did
you know that?”
“Know it? My dear child! how often have I dined at the
Pauls’? Just so often have I heard it.”
“Now, Billy, that’s not very nice in you.”
“I but stated a fact; and I have a high regard for Mrs. Paul.
Only, when I think how many girls she has tried to make marry
me!—but they would none of them look at me.”
“And in two weeks the opportunity will be gone,” she
jeered.
“Poor girls!” the minister commiserated; and was reproved for
vanity. Indeed, just because happiness is so serious a thing, they
became very frivolous, these two, sitting watching the sunset, and
the river. Amy told him a funny story about the parish; he
responded by another concerning Tom Reilly, a policeman; which
reminded Amy to tell him that poor Tom had had an accident, and
hurt his hand.
“But it was very stupid in him,” she added, with a little of
that resentful goodness that one sees sometimes in women. “I’m not
at all sorry for him, because he deserved it. He had been drinking,
and as he went stumbling out of a car, he crushed his hand in the
door.”Her lover was not to be lured into professional comments; he
only muttered, “Mauvais quart d’heure”—which made her say indignantly: “Now, Billy, really, that
istoomuch!” and insist that
they should go home immediately. “I cannot descend to such levels,”
she told him; and was very stern and forbidding when, looking to
the right and left, and seeing no man, he begged to be allowed to
kiss her.But this was all froth. Beneath, in the man’s life, were the
great tides of love, moving, noiseless and unchangeable, from out
the depths of his soul. In the girl’s life it was all shine and
perfume and glitter, like flowers blossoming on a rock; beneath, in
her heart, was the solid ground of reverence and faith.IIThe two weeks that were to pass before the day that was to be
the Day of Days were very full.To get parish work ahead so that things would run themselves
for the month’s absence which had been granted the clergyman was no
small undertaking. William West was very busy, and a little
preoccupied in his endeavor to put his best thought, not upon his
own happiness, but upon committees, or Sunday-school matters, or
his assistant’s spiritual anxieties concerning his superior’s
indifference to the color of the lectern bookmarks; so it chanced
that he saw less of Amy than in the earlier part of their
engagement. He had but little time to think of her, and absolutely
no time to think of himself.They were to be married on Thursday. Late Monday afternoon
Mr. West, with great timidity, ventured into Mrs. Paul’s
drawing-room, with the bold purpose of abstracting his sweetheart
for a walk. The project was, of course, promptly
crushed.
“As though Amy had any time for that sort of thing!” said
Mrs. Paul. “Do you see those presents? She has got to acknowledge
every one of them! Amy, your cousin John and I will entertain Mr.
West. You can write your notes here, and let him look at you;
that’s quite enough for him.”Amy smiled at him across a barricade of silver
bric-à-brac.
“Billy thinks silver picture-frames and brushes and things
are a dreadful waste of money,” she said. “Just think how thankful
you ought to be, Billy, that I am making our manners for you; you
couldn’t say ‘Thank you,’ with truth.”
“Oh, truth,” said John Paul, lounging about the room, with
his hands in his pockets—“truth, my dear little cousin, is governed
by the law of benefit; didn’t you know that? If it makes the donors
feel happy, tell them West has longed for nothing in the world so
much as a silver glove buttoner. Now, if you told them the truth,
fancy the shock! Ask the Parson.”
“The Parson has no such base and cynical theory,” Miss
Townsend responded promptly; “have you, Billy? You don’t think
truth is governed by the law of benefit?”
“I think truth-telling is,” he assured her.John Paul assumed that look of artless and simpering
satisfaction which one sees on the countenance of the unprotected
male, who, in the bosom of his family, finds himself indorsed by a
higher power.
“There, Amy, what did I tell you? I had an instance of it
yesterday. I”—
“Oh, here is a third asparagus fork,” murmured Amy;
“whatshallI say about
it?”
“What’s your instance?” said the minister.
“Well, we’ve been looking for an assistant engineer, and
there have been the Lord only knows how many applicants. One fellow
impressed me very well; he seemed as straight as a string; honest
face, thoroughly decent-looking fellow. He was an Englishman, but
his references for three years were American. So much the better,
of course. I was going to engage him, when, bless my soul, if he
didn’t begin to stammer out something about having no references
from ‘Home’ (‘’ome,’ he called it), because he ‘’adn’t been over
steady,’ but he’d signed the pledge, and ‘he wasn’t afraid of drink
any more.’ I didn’t hire him. Now, I call that truth not governed
by the law of benefit.”
“You don’t discriminate between being truthful and telling
the truth,” said William West. “You hadn’t asked him if he had ever
drank. I don’t believe you lost much, in not engaging him, poor
fellow.”
“Oh, Billy, I think it was rather fine in him,” Amy
protested, looking up from her notes.
“I don’t see anything fine,” the minister said simply. “In
the first place, there was a lack of reserve, a lack of privacy, in
rushing into confession, which betrays the weak nature. There was
also self-consciousness, in dwelling on his sin. And in the third
place”—
“This sounds like a sermon: firstly—secondly”—Amy murmured,
signing her name to her thanks for the third asparagus
fork.
—“in the third place, if the man has reformed, there was an
essential untruth in posing as a sinner.”
“Well, I don’t quite agree with that,” began Mrs.
Paul.
“He’s right; he’s right,” John Paul declared. “I say, West,
suppose we went about confessing some of our college performances?”
The senior warden of St. James grinned, but his wife looked
displeased.
“I don’t believe you ever did anything very bad, John; but if
you did, I think you should have confessed to me.”
“I stole some signs, Kate,” he told her; “can you forgive
me?”Amy, listening, smiling, said with that charming sidewise
glance at her lover: “Cousin Kate is quite right. I should never
forgive a man who didn’t tell me everything! Billy, come here and
confess. Have you ever done anything wicked?”
“We are all miserable sinners,” John Paul murmured. “I say so
publicly every Sunday”—
“But you don’t specify!” the minister reminded him, with a
laugh.
“Yes; but, Billy,” Amy Townsend insisted, “doesn’t it say
somewhere that ‘confession is good for the soul’?”
“Perhaps it is,” he said dryly, “but, generally speaking,
it’s mighty bad for the mind.”There was an outcry at this from the two women.
“Of course,” Mrs. Paul said, “simply gossiping about one’s
self isn’t confession; but don’t you think, Mr. West, in the really
deep relations of life, between friend and friend, or husband and
wife, there should be no reserves?”
“My dear Mrs. Paul,” he answered, with quick gravity, “there
must be reserves—except with God. The human soul is solitary. But
for confession, that is different; justice and reparation sometimes
demand it; but, again, justice and courage sometimes forbid it.
Unless it is necessary, it is flabby vanity. That’s why I said it
was bad for the mind.”
“Well,” said Amy, with some spirit, “I don’t believe in
taking respect, or—or love, on false pretenses. If I had ever done
any dreadful thing, I should want to confess; good gracious, for
the mere comfort of it I should have to! It would be like walking
on a volcano to keep a secret.”William West went over to the table where she was writing,
and, finding a place among the clutter of presents to lean his
elbow, sat down and looked at her with good-humored
amusement.
“Where are you going to draw the line? How far back are you
going in confessing your sins? Please don’t tell me that you
slapped your nurse when you were three. It would be a horrible
shock, and make me very unhappy to discover such a
crime.”
“I shall go all the way back,” said Amy, with decision; “if I
had done anything wrong, I mean very wrong, I should tell you,—if I
had only been a year old!”The minister laughed. “A desperate villain of one year!” he
said; but as he spoke a puzzled look came into his eyes.
“I think,” Amy Townsend proceeded, “that honor and fairness
demand speaking out. And as for making some one else unhappy,” her
voice dropped a little, and the color came up into her face, “where
people love each other, they have a right to
unhappiness.”
“Listen to Amy clamoring for unhappiness!” John Paul
commented. “Don’t worry, my child; you’ll get your share. There’s
enough to go round, I’ve noticed.”Mrs. Paul laughed, but a note of reality had come into the
careless talk that gave her a sense of being a third
party.
“John, you are flippant,” she said; “come, let’s leave these
two poor things alone; they’re dying to get rid of us. And besides,
if Amy is going to confess her sins since she was one year old, it
will take time.”
“That I consider a most uncalled for reference to my
twenty-seven years,” Amy retorted; “and besides, I’ve two more
notes to write.”
“And I must go home,” William West said, rising in a
preoccupied manner.
“Why—but I thought you were going to stay to dinner!” Mrs.
Paul protested, with dismay.
“Oh, you must stay to dinner,” Amy urged.But her lover was resolute. Nor did he, as usual, try to lure
her out into the hall that he might make his adieus. He said
good-night, stopped a moment to discuss with his senior warden
something about the appropriation for repairs at St. James, and
then, with a sober abstraction deepening in his face, went home
through the delicate June dusk, which was full of the scent of the
roses that grow behind the garden walls of the old-fashioned part
of Mercer.IIIThe Rev. William West went into his study and shut the door.
He was a man who was always accessible to his people, yet his lips
tightened with impatience when he found a parishioner awaiting him,
and saw a pile of notes on his writing-table. But it was only for
an instant; he listened to the anxieties of his caller with that
concentration of sympathy which can put self aside; and when the
man went away it was with the other man’s heartfelt grip of the
hand, his heartfelt “I thank you for coming to me; God bless you,
my friend, and give you wisdom.”The letters were not so easy; but he went through them
faithfully, answering them or filing them away: appeals for help,
or money, or work; two invitations; two letters from ladies of his
congregation about their souls; the unmarried and interesting
clergyman knows this sort of letter too well! He was aware of a
sense of haste in getting through with these things; a sense of
haste even in disposing of another caller, a boy, who came to say
he had doubts about the existence of God, and who felt immensely
important in consequence. “I tell you, Mr. West,” this youth
declared, nodding his head, “of course I don’t mean to be hard on
the church; of course I see the value of such a belief in keeping
the masses straight, but, for thinking men!” To treat this sort of
thing seriously and patiently is one of the trials of a thinking
man who happens to be a minister. Then the Tenor came to give his
side of the quarrel with the Bass, and the organist to say that
quartette and chorus were all fools.One does not prove the existence of God, or pacify wounded
artistic feelings easily; it was nearly midnight before the
clergyman had his library to himself.With a sigh of relief he shut the door, and walked once or
twice about the room, as though trying to shake off other people’s
affairs; then he bit off the end of a cigar, struck a match, and
sat down. He put his hands deep into his pockets, and stretched his
feet straight out in front of him.
“It must be five years since I’ve thought of it,” he said to
himself.He held his lighted cigar between his fingers, his chin sunk
on his breast, his mouth set in that hard line which refuses to
extenuate or evade; his eyes narrowed with thought. Five years:
Yes, the memory had so faded and lessened that by and by it had
ceased, and now it was as though, as he walked along the level path
of daily life, a serpent suddenly lifted its evil head from the
dust, and struck at him, hissing.
“I was eighteen,” he said to himself; “no, nineteen. And now
I’m forty-two! Twenty-nine, thirty-nine—it’s twenty-three years
ago.”There is a hideous consciousness which comes to most of us
men and women at one time or another in our lives, of our inability
to get away from the past. From out of the “roaring loom of Time”
comes the fabric of our lives; white, run, perhaps, with a warp of
silver in our latter years; set, even, by the mercy of God, with
deep jewels of experience; spangled with golden threads of
opportunity; but back, in its beginnings—what stains, what rents!
dragged through what foul and primeval experiences of youth! Some,
by environment and temperament, have nothing to blush for but
follies; the joyous baseness of the young animal never broke
through the conditions of their lives, or the dullness of their
minds. But for most there are black spots from which, with wonder
and disgust, the adult turns away his eyes: the cruelty and
impurity of childhood; the ingratitude and meanness of youth. With
the man, as with the race, that is not first which is spiritual,
but that which is natural.Twenty-three years ago: is there any connection between a
fault committed then and the William West of to-day? None! What has
he in common with the boy of nineteen? Nothing!Suppose he told Amy, would she understand that? Why, the very
fact that he had forgotten it meant that he did not belong to it,
nor it to him. And yet he wanted to tell h [...]