0,49 €
Niedrigster Preis in 30 Tagen: 1,99 €
Niedrigster Preis in 30 Tagen: 1,99 €
Mehr erfahren.
- Herausgeber: Booksell-Verlag
- Kategorie: Religion und Spiritualität
- Sprache: Englisch
In "Magic and Religion," Andrew Lang explores the intricate tapestry weaving together the realms of magic, myth, and religious practice. Employing a comparative approach, Lang delves into diverse cultural traditions and belief systems, elucidating how magical practices often coexist with, and sometimes predate, organized religion. His literary style is characterized by a blend of analytical rigor and vivid narrative, drawing on ethnographic evidence and folklore to illustrate the universal themes that underpin human spirituality. This work emerges against the backdrop of 19th-century anthropology, a time when the scientific study of culture was blossoming, and offers insights that resonate with contemporary debates in the field. Andrew Lang, a Scottish folklorist, anthropologist, and writer, was deeply immersed in the study of mythology and folklore throughout his scholarly career. His wide-ranging interests were informed by his travels and exposure to various cultures, fostering a belief in the interconnectedness of human experience. Lang's contributions to the understanding of narrative and belief provide a foundational perspective in this area, drawing on his extensive knowledge of anthropology and literature. This book is essential reading for anyone intrigued by the origins of belief systems and the role of magic in societal structures. Lang's deep insights and engaging style make complex ideas accessible, encouraging readers to reconsider the boundaries between magic and religion. "Magic and Religion" is not merely a scholarly text; it is a thought-provoking journey into the heart of human culture. In this enriched edition, we have carefully created added value for your reading experience: - A succinct Introduction situates the work's timeless appeal and themes. - The Synopsis outlines the central plot, highlighting key developments without spoiling critical twists. - A detailed Historical Context immerses you in the era's events and influences that shaped the writing. - A thorough Analysis dissects symbols, motifs, and character arcs to unearth underlying meanings. - Reflection questions prompt you to engage personally with the work's messages, connecting them to modern life. - Hand‐picked Memorable Quotes shine a spotlight on moments of literary brilliance. - Interactive footnotes clarify unusual references, historical allusions, and archaic phrases for an effortless, more informed read.
Das E-Book können Sie in Legimi-Apps oder einer beliebigen App lesen, die das folgende Format unterstützen:
Veröffentlichungsjahr: 2021
Ähnliche
Magic and Religion
Table of Contents
Introduction
At the shifting border where ritual practice shades into devotional belief, Andrew Lang examines how people make meaning out of the unseen. Magic and Religion introduces readers to a wide-ranging inquiry that crosses disciplines to ask what, if anything, truly separates magic from religion. Without telling a story in the fictional sense, the book instead traces arguments and examples that move across eras and cultures. Lang draws readers into a debate that is both conceptual and human, inviting attention to the ways fear, hope, memory, and social custom shape the forms of reverence and the techniques of enchantment.
This is a scholarly work of comparative religion and anthropology by the Scottish writer and folklorist Andrew Lang, first published in the early twentieth century, when theories of cultural evolution and the origins of belief were vigorously contested. Its setting is intellectual rather than geographical: the evidence ranges from classical texts to reports about practices from diverse communities, viewed through the lens of the period’s scholarship. The book’s publication context places it amid heated discussions about whether ritual, myth, and worship develop along a single track or arise from multiple sources, a question that frames much of Lang’s approach.
Readers encounter a sequence of essays that test definitions, weigh examples, and probe assumptions rather than a single linear thesis. The experience is discursive yet controlled: Lang’s voice is urbane, argumentative, and attentive to counterevidence, and his prose blends learned reference with plainspoken scrutiny. Though the subject is abstract, the mood is exploratory rather than doctrinaire, encouraging readers to compare cases and to watch how distinctions are made and unmade. The result is a reflective, critical journey through the categories scholars use—magic, religion, taboo, myth—showing how these words organize, and sometimes distort, the behaviors they aim to describe.
Among its central themes is the tension between practices meant to compel outcomes and those that appeal to powers beyond human control, and the book asks whether this contrast is as firm as it appears. Lang examines how communities articulate the sacred, how ritual may move from utility toward worship, and how myth can anchor authority or inspire reform. He attends to questions of first principles—what counts as evidence for the earliest forms of belief—and to the intellectual capacities attributed to different societies. Throughout, he resists neat progressions, suggesting that coexistence and overlap often explain more than any single evolutionary ladder.
Methodologically, the book is comparative and evidential, moving back and forth between particular cases and general claims. Lang sifts travelers’ accounts, missionary records, classical literature, and folklore, demonstrating how conclusions can depend on the quality and context of sources. He dissects definitions with care, showing how a shift in wording can reclassify an entire practice. The argumentative arc stresses restraint: broad theories should be tested against multiple lines of testimony and revised when exceptions multiply. Readers thus see not only the claims under review but also the scholarly habits—close reading, cross-checking, and skepticism—that enable more reliable interpretations.
Contemporary readers may value the book as a window onto foundational debates about belief while recognizing that its language reflects the era that produced it. The materials and methods it assembles invite questions that remain urgent today: what standards of evidence are fair across cultures, how scholarship should handle partial or biased reports, and where analytic categories clarify or conceal lived experience. It also speaks to ongoing fascination with enchantment in secular societies, illustrating how rituals and narratives endure by meeting emotional needs and organizing communal life. The work’s historical position clarifies both its insights and the limits that modern readers will want to keep in view.
Approached as an invitation to think rather than a set of settled doctrines, Magic and Religion offers a challenging, rewarding study in how humans seek meaning, agency, and connection. Its pages cultivate the patience to compare like with unlike, the humility to live with uncertainty, and the curiosity to follow evidence wherever it leads. Readers come away with sharpened questions about the boundary between technique and faith, about the uses of myth, and about the responsibilities of interpretation. The book’s enduring appeal lies in that intellectual hospitality: it opens a space where competing explanations can be tested, revised, and imaginatively understood.
Synopsis (Selection)
Andrew Lang’s Magic and Religion examines how magical practices and religious beliefs intersect, diverge, and coexist across societies. Composed as a series of essays, the book surveys ethnographic reports, historical testimonies, and contemporary debates in anthropology. Lang outlines the prevailing evolutionary schemes of his time, then tests them against a wide range of examples. He engages with leading theorists, scrutinizing definitions and the evidentiary basis on which broad conclusions are drawn. The work’s central task is descriptive and comparative: to clarify what is meant by “magic” and “religion,” to trace their relations in different cultures, and to assess whether standard developmental models adequately fit the observed facts.
Early chapters establish terms and method. Lang distinguishes ritual technique aimed at controlling events (magic) from worship directed toward personal beings (religion), while noting how the two often overlap in practice. He cautions that anthropological generalizations frequently rest on fragmentary or biased sources. To address this, he compiles cross-cultural cases and weighs them against theoretical claims. He outlines the dominant view that human thought moves from magic to religion and then to science, and he sets out to test this sequence. The book’s structure proceeds from definitional questions to targeted case studies, then returns to broader theoretical implications.
Lang’s treatment of magic emphasizes its logic of analogy and contact—processes commonly labeled sympathetic and contagious magic. He describes how such procedures aim at practical results, resembling experimental method but lacking controlled verification. Magic appears among many peoples and social strata, often maintained by specialists whose authority rests on tradition, secrecy, or reputation. While sometimes tolerated, magic can conflict with religious norms where prayer, divine will, and moral obedience are emphasized. Lang also surveys taboos and prohibitions as protective techniques adjacent to magic. Throughout, he questions the assumption that a neat historical transition moves uniformly from magical manipulation to pious worship.
Turning to religion, Lang compiles reports of high or Supreme Beings in societies often labeled “primitive.” These deities—frequently sky-associated creators or guardians—are sometimes addressed in prayer and linked to moral sanctions. Such evidence challenges theories that religion arose solely from ghost-fear, ancestral cults, or the deification of nature. Lang’s argument is cumulative: he compares independent cases across continents, noting recurring attributes such as creative power, beneficence, and ethical oversight. He considers the possibility that ideas of a Supreme Being need not be late borrowings or degradations of earlier cults. Instead, they may coexist with, precede, or outlast other ritual complexes.
Lang next examines totemism, the clan-based system involving animal or plant emblems, exogamy, and food taboos. He questions whether totemism can serve as a universal key to the origin of religion. Surveying groups in Australia and elsewhere, he notes that totemic practices vary widely and often appear alongside beliefs in a high god. While totemic prohibitions regulate kinship and resource use, they do not necessarily generate worship of personal deities. Lang therefore resists theories that derive sacrifice, priesthood, or mythology entirely from totemic cults. He stresses that multiple strands—social, ritual, mythic—interlace without a single, uniform ancestry.
Addressing myth and ritual, Lang disputes blanket claims about priority. Sometimes ritual seeks an authoritative narrative and generates myth; in other cases, stories exist independently or are later rationalizations. He catalogues examples where myth appears playful, aetiological, or moralizing rather than strictly liturgical. Sacrifice receives careful discussion: whether it feeds, propitiates, or symbolizes varies by culture and context. Lang analyzes purity and taboo not as a single doctrine but as diverse constraints that shape social order. Across these inquiries, he emphasizes variability of sequence: there is no necessary law that ritual everywhere precedes myth, or vice versa; each tradition must be assessed on its merits.
Prayer and morality form another focus. Lang collects instances where communities appeal to a deity for justice, weather, health, or guidance, indicating religious expectations of personal response rather than mechanical efficacy. He notes moral prohibitions and ideals linked to divine sanction, countering portrayals of early religion as purely magical or amoral. Reports of name-avoidance, sky symbolism, and aniconism show reverence without idols. At the same time, myths can introduce inconsistencies or anthropomorphic episodes that seem to lower a god’s dignity. Lang interprets such tensions as historical accretions and narrative elaborations, distinguishing a reverent, ethical stratum from later, often entertaining, mythic embroidery.
Lang also addresses the persistence of magic in advanced societies. Charms, divination, witchcraft accusations, and protective rituals survive alongside formal religious observance and scientific thought. Their endurance complicates linear models of intellectual progress. He surveys how institutional religions may condemn, tolerate, or incorporate such practices. This continuity demonstrates that magical and religious logics can coexist within the same culture and even the same individual. Rather than marking discrete stages, they function as overlapping strategies for managing uncertainty, fate, and misfortune. By documenting these survivals, Lang reinforces his broader theme: history does not support a single, universal ladder of belief.
In conclusion, Magic and Religion argues that magic and religion are distinguishable yet entangled traditions, neither reducible to the other nor arranged in a uniform evolutionary sequence. Lang emphasizes careful comparison, source criticism, and sensitivity to local contexts. He highlights evidence for early, ethical conceptions of a Supreme Being in several societies, while acknowledging the complexity introduced by totemism, taboo, myth, and sacrifice. The book’s overarching message is methodological and substantive: explanatory schemes must match the diversity of facts, and religious origins cannot be confined to one pathway. Magic and religion persist as interacting, historically layered modes of human practice.
Historical Context
Magic and Religion appeared in 1901, at the hinge of Victorian and Edwardian Britain, amid the global reach of the British Empire and a confident, sometimes combative, scientific culture. Written by the Scottish classicist and folklorist Andrew Lang, and published in London, the book reflects debates circulating through metropolitan institutions such as the Royal Anthropological Institute and the Folklore Society. The death of Queen Victoria in January 1901 and the accession of Edward VII framed a period of imperial surveys, missionary reporting, and comparative scholarship. Lang’s essays were composed against this background of accelerated ethnographic collecting, fierce controversy over the origins of religion, and rapid publicization of evolutionary ideas.
The Darwinian revolution provided the most consequential backdrop. Charles Darwin’s On the Origin of Species (1859) and The Descent of Man (1871) emboldened comparative sciences to seek lawful sequences in human culture. Edward B. Tylor’s Primitive Culture (1871) proposed animism as the earliest religious form and popularized the idea of survivals, while Lewis H. Morgan’s Ancient Society (1877) advanced unilinear stages of social evolution. The Royal Anthropological Institute, reorganized in 1871, institutionalized these approaches in London. Lang’s book engages this climate by testing evolutionary claims against a wide dossier of customs, rites, and myths, often challenging neat progressions and arguing that religion and magic interpenetrate rather than succeed one another in a fixed order.
James George Frazer’s system was a central historical provocation. The Golden Bough first appeared in 1890 and was expanded in a second edition in 1900, from Trinity College, Cambridge. Frazer classified magic under the laws of similarity and contact, then posited a grand sequence from magic to religion to science, using the priest of Nemi and the cult of Diana as emblematic. Lang, a constant interlocutor, accepted Frazer’s learning but disputed the rigid chronology and the reduction of early belief to failed pseudo-science. In Magic and Religion he reexamines sympathetic rites, fertility cults, and sacrificial motifs, arguing that high gods and moral sanctions are attested among so called primitive peoples, complicating Frazer’s evolutionary ladder.
Debates on totemism and Australian ethnography shaped Lang’s arguments. Missionary ethnologists Lorimer Fison and A. W. Howitt published Kamilaroi and Kurnai in 1879, describing exogamous classes, kinship, and totems in southeastern Australia. The most dramatic fieldwork arrived with Walter Baldwin Spencer and F. J. Gillen’s The Native Tribes of Central Australia (1899), based in places such as Alice Springs and Barrow Creek among Arrernte communities. They reported churinga, increase ceremonies, and complex local cults. Lang mined these records to contest speculative schemes of group marriage and to reassess the relation between totemic ritual, myth, and belief in supreme beings like Baiame. He used Australian data to argue that religion need not be a late derivative of magic.
Psychical research formed a controversial but important context. The Society for Psychical Research was founded in London in 1882 by Henry Sidgwick, Frederic Myers, and colleagues. Its Phantasms of the Living (1886) and the Census of Hallucinations (1894) compiled thousands of testimonies on apparitions, telepathy, and crisis visions. Lang, an active participant, linked such experiences to the ethnographic record of visions, divination, and shamanic phenomena. In Magic and Religion he leverages these inquiries to undermine a dismissive view of magical belief, proposing that recurrent experiences across classes and continents help explain the persistence of divination and spirit doctrines, even while he tests them against stringent standards of testimony and cross cultural comparison.
The controversies of biblical higher criticism also pressed upon comparative religion. Julius Wellhausen’s Prolegomena zur Geschichte Israels (1878–1883) and William Robertson Smith’s Lectures on the Religion of the Semites (1889) reinterpreted sacrifice, taboo, and myth through historical reconstruction. Smith’s heresy trial and removal from his Aberdeen Free Church chair in 1881 dramatized the stakes of these inquiries in Britain. Lang engaged these debates by challenging some reconstructions of sacrificial origins and by tracing parallels between Semitic, Greek, and so called savage rites without endorsing a single linear derivation. His discussions register the period’s struggle to reconcile religious tradition with historical method, and they press for a plural genealogy of ritual practice.
Imperial networks supplied the documents that made Lang’s comparisons possible. The Cambridge Anthropological Expedition to the Torres Straits in 1898, led by A. C. Haddon with W. H. R. Rivers and C. G. Seligman, pioneered intensive field methods; its Reports began appearing in 1901. Missionary ethnographies such as R. H. Codrington’s The Melanesians (1891) and colonial travelogues like Mary Kingsley’s Travels in West Africa (1897) fed London libraries with case studies on magic, taboo, and spirit cults. The Folklore Society, founded in 1878, marshaled questionnaires and regional surveys across the empire. Magic and Religion stands amid this archive, sifting administrative, missionary, and scientific testimony to test general propositions about ritual and belief.
Lang’s book functions as a social and political critique by exposing the complacencies of imperial rationalism. He challenges the notion that colonized peoples simply enact failed science, showing instead that European publics and elites share cognate magical habits in lotteries, relic veneration, and dreams. By questioning unilinear evolution and overconfident biblical or secular orthodoxies, he unsettles hierarchies that justified empire and missionary coercion. His emphasis on the moral authority of high gods in small scale societies rebukes stereotypes of inherent savagery. In method and tone, Magic and Religion calls for disciplined evidence and intellectual humility, critiquing the era’s tendency to turn difference into a ladder of rank.
