How They CaughtJeffrey Dahmer
Dylan Frost© Copyright 2025 Dylan Frost
-
ContentsWho was Jeffrey Dahmer?How They Caught Jeffrey Dahmer Part 1How They Caught Jeffrey Dahmer Part 2How They Caught Jeffrey Dahmer Part 3What Happened to Jeffrey Dahmer Afterwards? Photo CreditWHO WAS JEFFREY DAHMER?Jeffrey
Lionel Dahmer was born in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, in 1960. He was an
outcast from an early age although he was always quite intelligent.
Dahmer could never seem to find any direction in his life though and
eventually succumbed to the dark demons which resided within him.
Dahmer always seemed to have a morbid fascination with the science of
death and decomposition from an early age. This would escalate into
necrophilia and even cannibalism. Dahmer became a heavy drinker at an
unusually young age and would take alcohol to school with him to
secretly drink. His heavy drinking made regular employment a constant
struggle for Dahmer and greatly affected his chances of a good
education. Jeffrey Dahmer was smart enough to have good academic
potential but he was never able to take advantage of this. Dahmer was
gay and become increasingly overcome with fantasies where he could
dominate a male lover. Dahmer's ultimate fantasy was to exert his power
over someone who couldn't move or was dead. Tragically, he would make
these fantasies a grim reality in his life. Dahmer murdered
someone for the first time in 1978 when he was just eighteen.
Circumstances had left Dahmer living alone for a time as his mother had
moved out and his father was in a motel. Dahmer picked up a young
hitchhiker and took him home for a drink. When the hitchhiker was
distracted, Dahmer hit him twice with a dumbbell and then throttled him
with the weight. He dissected the body and buried it. Later he dug up
the remains and used acid to dispose of the flesh. He crushed the bones
with a hammer so they would easy to dispose of. Dahmer was more precise
and careful when it came to disposing of bodies than your average
serial killer. He had an aptitude for science - something which
obviously helped in his grisly stock-in-trade. As his grasp on reality
(never very firm to begin with) started to frazzle and evaporate
though, Dahmer would become less studious at removing traces of his
crimes. He seemed to develop a particular fascination with the skulls
of his victims and would keep them as if they were trophies he had won.
Dahmer's father paid for him to go university but he dropped
out after a few months and ended up joining the armed forces. He served
as a combat medic in 2nd Battalion, 68th Armored Regiment, 8th Infantry
Division, and spent some time in what was then West Germany. Two
soldiers later claimed that Dahmer had drugged and raped them during
his service. After his discharge from the army, Dahmer worked in a food
outlet for a time in Florida and then ended up living with his
grandmother in West Allis, Wisconsin. It was hoped that his grandmother
might be a good influence on Dahmer but it was in these years that his
dark demons took hold again and set him on course to become one of the
most infamous serial killers in American criminal history.Dahmer
was arrested for indecent exposure around this time and also began to
investigate the gay scene in the area. He became aware that it was
relatively easy to pick up young men and as he was living with just his
grandmother he had a relative sort of privacy at home. Dahmer
frequented local bathhouses and would drug other patrons so that he
could sexually abuse them. Late in 1987, Dahmer killed again. He rented
a room in a hotel and awoke to find a dead man he had spent the night
with. Dahmer claimed to have no memory of the murder. He transported
the body out of the hotel in suitcases and went back to his
grandmother's house where he dissected the body and pounded the bones
up. Dahmer kept the skull for a time and then disposed of this too.
Dahmer became a persistent killer from this point. There would be
seventeen official victims in all. Dahmer's known victims were Steven
Hicks, James Doxtator, Richard Guerrero, Anthony Sears, Raymond Smith,
Edward Smith, Ernist Miller, David Thomas, Curtis Straughter, Errol
Lindsey, Tony Hughes, Konerak Sinthasomphone, Matt Turner, Jeremiah
Weinberger, Oliver Lacy and Joseph Bradehaft. Dahmer
eventually moved into his own apartment and although this made bringing
men back and killing them easier it also made disposing of the evidence
harder. It was a more constrictive environment. Dahmer was by now
completely lost in his own world of murder and depravity. He would pose
the bodies of victims and take photographs. Skulls were kept in closets
like a trophy case and he would mummify body parts to keep. Dahmer
would boil flesh down to fat and bleach bones and skulls so they could
be preserved. He spray painted one skull to make a macabre work of art.
After drugging one victim, Dahmer drilled a hole in his skull and
poured hydrochloric acid into it. His youngest victim was fourteen
years old. There was no line that Dahmer didn't cross. He was not just
a serial killer but a necrophile and a cannibal. By July 1991, the
thirty-one year-old Dahmer was living at Oxford Apartments - located at
924 N. 25th St in Milwaukee. His apartment number was 213. A
former neighbour of Dahmer said he always looked a bit dirty and in
need of a shower. The manager of Dahmer's apartment building described
Jeffrey Dahmer as a loner but not someone who caused any problems. He
said Dahmer always paid his rent on time. Residents of Oxford
Apartments said that Dahmer stood out like a sore thumb because he was
practically the only white person who lived there. No one could have
guessed the horror, depravity and terror which abounded behind the door
of apartment 213. Jeffrey Dahmer's apartment was so eventually so full
with victims and body parts that he put one body in the bath and had to
shower over it. The apartment contained a plastic drum of acid where
three human torsos were dissolving. Body parts were wrapped and stored
in the fridge and bloodstains were visible on his mattress and some of
the wall. The police later found two bags in Jeffrey Dahmer's fridge
that contained human hearts. Dahmer had lost his job at a local
chocolate factory and was fearful that he might be kicked out of his
apartment in the end. If this happened he would be in big
trouble because he still had copious amounts of forensic evidence in
his apartment that he appeared to have little chance of disposing of in
the immediate future. As of July 1991, the police were yet to deduce
that a cannibal serial killer was active in Milwaukee. Milwaukee was
perhaps best known for being where the sitcom Happy Days is set but it
was now about to be connected to one of the most famous and disturbing
killers in history. Dahmer, who was now completely dominated by his
sick desires, was now trying to murder a new person on a weekly basis -
which was prolific even by the grim standards of serial killers. On the
night of July 22, 1991, Dahmer persuaded a thirty-one year-old man
named Tracy Edwards to come back to his apartment to pose for
photographs. This was the ruse that Dahmer would use to lure victims.
He would offer money to men to pose for photographs in his apartment
and then murder them. Though he didn't know it at the time, Dahmer's
luck was about to finally run out. He'd had a few close shaves before
with victims escaping or not being sedated properly but none of these
incidents threatened his status as a secret serial killer or threatened
to expose him. This time though would be very different...HOW THEY CAUGHT JEFFREY DAHMER PART 1Jeffrey
Dahmer said his necrophiliac desires began when he was fourteen. A
necrophiliac is a person who is sexually excited by or attracted to
dead bodies. When he was growing-up, Jeffrey Dahmer once stole a
mannequin from a store and kept it in his bedroom for a couple of
weeks. Sadly, this mannequin only served to make him wish he had a real
inert body to lie down with. Dahmer said he threw the stolen mannequin
away because his grandmother found it and thought it was a weird thing
to have. How did Dahmer steal the mannequin from a store? Dahmer said
he hid and got himself locked in and when everyone went home and they
closed up he put a sleeping bag over it and took a taxi home. Dahmer
said he kept the mannequin for about two weeks. He said he pretended it
was a real person and cuddled it in bed. Dahmer also said that when he
was eighteen he tried to steal a corpse from a graveyard but his plan
was foiled because the ground was too hard to dig up. Dahmer had read
in the obituary section of the newspaper that a local teenage boy had
died. Dahmer said that when he tried to dig up the body in the
graveyard he was attacked by a dog. Dahmer's friends said he was
obsessed with graveyards. If we flash forward to 1991 we see that
Dahmer's obsession with necrophillia has reached its terrible and
perhaps inevitable end. Jeffrey Dahmer's apartment was so
eventually so full with victims and body parts that he put one body in
the bath and had to shower over it. According to some sources Dahmer
had TWO bodies in the shower in the end. Neighbours of Jeffrey Dahmer
did complain about the smell coming from his apartment several times.
He apparently told them once that his freezer broke and some food went
bad. The way Dahmer got the victims back to his apartment was to offer
them money for a photoshoot or sex. They evidently didn't detect any
danger from him and so took the chance to make some extra cash. Dahmer
was bespectacled and mild in temperament and speech so he wasn't
someone who raised obvious alarm bells or seemed dangerous. Dahmer
would usually offer his victims $75 to come back to his apartment for a
photography session. His victims were always broke so took the bait.
Dahmer would sometimes get his victims handcuffed by telling them he
wanted to take a bondage photograph. Once the victim was handcuffed it
was game over because they now had little means to defend themselves.
Handcuffs and sleeping pills were a vital part of Dahmer's serial
killer 'kit'. Both were vital to ensure a victim could not resist and
fight back. When Dahmer moved into his own apartment this made
bringing men back and killing them much easier but it also made
disposing of the evidence much harder. It was a more constrictive
environment with no immediate access to quiet outdoor spaces.
Nonetheless, despite these drawbacks, Dahmer was soon completely lost
in his own world of murder and depravity. The apartment of Jeffrey
Dahmer contained a big blue plastic drum of acid where three human
torsos were dissolving. It was truly a house (or apartment in this
case) of horrors. Jefffrey Dahmer lived in a rough part of Milwaukee
that had plenty of crime and a notoriously smelly sewer problem. This
is the only explanation for why the noises and smells from his
apartment didn't trigger more curiosity in his neighbours. Dahmer often
used a handsaw to cut up his victims. Dahmer owned a large hunting
knife with a rubber grip. He would often use this knife as part of the
process of dissecting a body. Dahmer was always naked when he
dismembered his victims. Dahmer said he did this not for kinky reasons
but because he wanted to avoid getting blood or cleaning chemicals on
his clothes. Jeffrey Dahmer tried to disguise the smell in his
apartment by venting it with a fan. One imagines that Dahmer was always
fighting a losing battle trying to mask the foul odours coming from his
apartment. Dahmer was initially more precise and careful when it came
to disposing of bodies than your average serial killer. He had an
aptitude for science - something which obviously helped in his grisly
stock-in-trade. As his grasp on reality (never very firm to begin with)
started to frazzle and evaporate, Dahmer would become less studious at
removing traces of his crimes. What didn't help was his obsession with
keeping flesh in the fridge and collection bones as trophies. When you
add in the fact he kept killing people then you can see how Dahmer
eventually ended up in a situation where he was trapped in an apartment
with considerable forensic murder evidence but no swift and easy way of
removing it. Dahmer took many photographs of his victims after he
murdered them. Dahmer's polaroids would show victims in various states
of dismemberment. Dahmer seemed to like to chronicle his dissection.
The polaroids Damer took of his victims included ones he took during
actual acts of necrophilia. He had a bolt lock on the outside of his
bedroom door. This was obviously designed to lock people in. Dahmer
said he would usually target victims who were alone. If he saw someone
with a group of friends he knew it would be too risky - unless he could
isolate them. the last person that Dahmer took home - Tracy Edwards -
was with two friends when Dahmer encountered him. However as we shall
see, Dahmer was cunning in the way he isolated the intended victim and
got rid of the other men. We tend to think that necrophile serial
killers only get a few days of sexual gratification out of the bodies
because of decomposition. This wasn't really the case with Dahmer
though because he continued to get sexual gratification out of the
bones, heads, and even the photographs. Dahmer said that he always
tried to keep his apartment tidy because this made him seem more normal
and less suspicious. The police found that Jeffrey Dahmer had extensive
security at his apartment. He had a complex series of locks and an
alarm system. This was not just to prevent people from escaping but
also to prevent uninvited guests or thieves from entering. Dahmer knew
only too well that if anyone took a good look inside his apartment his
secret life as a serial killer would be quickly exposed. After he
killed a victim, Dahmer would usually not dissect them for a couple of
days. He did this because he wanted the corpse to enjoy while it was
still 'fresh'. Dahmer used a black nylon strap to strangle some of his
victims. Dahmer's method of selecting victims was risky and
he'd had more than one close shave in the past where he could easily
have been unmasked as a serial killer. The most famous of these close
shaves involved a victim named Konerak Sinthasomphone. Dahmer had
previously sexually assaulted the brother of his murder victim Konerak
Sinthasomphone. This was just a strange coincidence. Dahmer didn't know
these victims were related. Dahmer poured acid into the head of Konerak
Sinthasomphone but Sinthasomphone escaped and wandered the streets in a
daze. Tragically, some policemen who found Sinthasomphone then took him
back to Dahmer's apartment after Dahmer told them Sinthasomphone was
his intoxicated boyfriend. Dahmer’s neighbour Sandra Smith had alerted
the police to Konerak Sinthasomphone wandering the street in a daze.
The police officers in this incident were highly lackadaisical because
they didn't even bother to do a background check on Dahmer or take a
proper look in his apartment. They just handed the victim back to him
and left. The police got a lot of criticism for this blunder when
Dahmer was later captured. They had basically handed Konerak
Sinthasomphone back to a serial killer to be murdered. John A.
Balcerzak and Joseph P. Gabrish were the bungling police officers who
handed the dazed and confused victim Konerak Sinthasomphone back to
Jeffrey Dahmer and certain death. They were dismissed from the police
after an investigation but then appealed and got reinstated. John A.
Balcerzak and Joseph P. Gabrishwere were caught on radio making
homophobic comments and joking about how they had reunited 'lovers'
after the incident. Dahmer was so crazy that he thought if he injected
acid or boiling water into a victim's brain they would become a
complaint slave for him. Dahmer performed his 'zombification'
experiments on four of the victims. John A. Balcerzak and Joseph
P. Gabrish didn't even bother to ask for identification to establish
how old Konerak Sinthasomphone really was. They also failed to take
much of a look inside Dahmer's apartment. The two police officers just
seemed to want to wash their hands of this affair and leave the scene
as quickly as possible. Dahmer told John A. Balcerzak and Joseph P.
Gabrish that Konerak Sinthasomphone's name was John Hmong. This was a
slight variation on the name of a doctor that Dahmer procured his
sleeping pills from. John A. Balcerzak and Joseph P. Gabrish
both later defended their actions in various interviews. They said that
Dahmer seemed perfectly calm and normal to them and they had no idea
that Konerak Sinthasomphone was so young. Dahmer told the police
officers that Sinthasomphone was nineteen. John A. Balcerzak and Joseph
P. Gabrish said they had little information to go on that night and
genuinely believed that this was just a case of someone having too much
to drink. John A. Balcerzak remained a police officer until his
retirement in 2017. Balcerzak later served as president of the
Milwaukee Police Association (the police union) from 2005 to 2009.
Balcerzak made a joke on the police radio about needing to be
'deloused' after the tragic incident where Konerak Sinthasomphone was
handed back to Dahmer. Dahmer was not the first (and sadly wouldn't be
the last) serial killer who benefited from a police reluctance to get
involved in disputes and crimes which related to the gay community.By
July of 1991, Dahmer was beginning to sense that he might be nearing
the end as far as his present circumstances were concerned. He was
running out of money and the human remains in his apartment had got to
a point where it was going to take a long time to remove them. Even if
he did somehow manage this he was only going to kill again anyway and
the whole grisly cycle would go back to square one. Serial killers tend
not to take much notice of obvious problems like this. The main problem
they face is that because they can't stop killing people they run the
risk of ending up like Dahmer in that apartment. It was no problem for
roaming killers like Ted Bundy - who was perfectly happy to murder
people anywhere - but Jeffrey Dahmer (aside from the hotel incident -
which was a drunken accident rather than premeditated) only killed at
his home. Mudering in an outside location was out of the question
because he needed ownership of the body to get full satisfaction. It
was obviously a lot easier for Dahmer to dispose of victims when he
lived with his father and then his grandmother because he had easy
quick access to woodland and relative privacy. Dahmer dissected three
men at his grandmother's house. She obviously had no idea what her
grandson was doing in the basement. When he moved to an apartment and
started killing people it obviously became a lot more complicated to
dispose of remains - hence the nightmarish situation he ended up in.
Dahmer, like most serial killers, had come to regard his macabre and
disturbing situation as the norm. He was lost in a bizarre world of his
own. There were some instances of Dahmer sedating someone but not
killing them. It is quite rare for serial killers to let a potential
victim go like this. It is generally assumed that Dahmer did not kill
these people because he deemed those specific situations too risky.
Dahmer said he only murdered people he was attracted to so it could be
the case that he let people go if he decided he wasn't attracted to
them in the end. Dahmer's murders escalated in the end to the point
where they almost piled up on one another. One could argue that he
began as an organised serial killer but as his descent into madness and
depravity went on he became a disorganised serial killer. Jeffrey
Dahmer said that he never really understood why he did the awful things
he did. He said it was like some dark compulsion he couldn't control.Dahmer's
apartment was, all things considered, rather ordinary and surprisingly
tidy. He had cream walls, a rug, paintings on the wall. The horrors
were hidden away in fridges, boxes, pans, drawers and out of the
way places - though bloodstains on his mattress and bedroom wall
betrayed the insanity of this man and the awful things he had done.
Dahmer's shopping bills were mostly taken up by cleaning fluids and
chemicals. There wasn't much in the way of actual food in the
apartment. Dahmer seemed to be subsisting on potato chips and beer. He
never was one for cooking at home. When he was employed at the
chocolate factory Dahmer would eat in a diner when he finished work.
The woman who had the apartment above Jeffrey Dahmer DID complain about
the smell and got moved. Those in charge of the building presumed it
must be a sewage problem. Dahmer's neighbours complained more than once
about strange noises and smells coming from Dahmer's apartment. No
action was taken though over these complaints and no one ever took a
good look inside Dahmer's apartment. Naturally, if there are complaints
about someone in an apartment block the last think you assume is that
they might be a serial killer. Dahmer had some creative
excuses for the smells that came from his apartment. When he was
questioned by the building supervisor about strange smells Dahmer told
him that the smell came from changing the water in his fish tank. A
former resident of Oxford Apartments where Dahmer lived said the whole
building stank at the best of times so this probably mitigated some of
the dreadful odours coming from Dahmer's apartment. When he was
captured, Dahmer told the police he was very surprised that the
residents in his building hadn't deduced anything because his apartment
was really starting to stink. In his police confession, Jeffrey Dahmer
said that he was dissolving bodies in a vat of acid because he had run
out of money and feared he would be thrown out of his apartment. He
wanted to destroy all evidence of his crimes before this happened.
Dahmer said that when he killed someone he got himself into a mindset
where the victim was not a person but an object designed purely for his
own pleasure. Dahmer claimed that he gave his victims sleeping pills
before strangulation because he didn't want them to suffer. He wanted
their death to be quick and unexpected. Dahmer wanted the victims to be
oblivious to their predicament.