Jack the Ripper - A Smorgasbord of Suspects
Dylan Frost© Copyright 2023 Dylan Frost
ContentsPrefaceIntroductionJoseph BarnettHenry Wentworth BellsmithWilliam Henry BuryLewis CarrollGeorge Chapman (aka Seweryn Antonowicz Klosowski)David CohenThomas Neill Cream Thomas Hayne CutbushFrederick Bailey DeemingMontague John DruittAmelia DyerBowen Endacott Carl FeigenbaumJoseph FlemingFogelmaWilliam Grant GraingerWilliam Withey GullLizzie HallidayJames HardimanH.H. HolmesGeorge HutchinsonHyam HyamsJacob IsenschmidJames KellyMichael KidneyAaron KosminskiCharles Allen Lechmere Charles Le GrandJacob Levy Robert MannJames MaybrickJohn McCarthyMichael OstrogMary PearceyJohn PizerJohn RichardsonWalter SickertJames Kenneth StephenRobert D'Onston StephensonThe Thames Torso KillerFrancis ThompsonFrancis TumbletyPrince Albert VictorSir John WilliamsPREFACEIn
1888, Jack the Ripper murdered and dismembered five women in the
Whitechapel district of London in brutal fashion. However, he was never
caught and we still don't know who he really was. The Ripper targeted
prostitutes and left some hideously gruesome crime scenes. He hacked
out internal organs and disfigured the faces of his unfortunate
victims. During the Jack the Ripper murders, Queen Victoria received
thousands of letters from women demanding that the police do more to
catch the killer. Alas though, the killer was never found. The
canonical victims were Mary Ann Nichols, Annie Chapman, Elizabeth
Stride, Catherine Eddowes, and Mary Jane Kelly. It is often presumed
though that other murders around this time might possibly have been the
work of the Ripper too. Some of the suspects we will examine
in this book are rather ludicrous but many are alarmingly plausible
too. There are many suspicious characters circa 1888 who feasibly could
have been Jack the Ripper. Deciding which one of them was most likely
to have been the killer though is no easy task. Some believe it is even
possible that the Ripper was some unknown person who has never been
mentioned as a suspect. Oddly, there are still too Ripper suspects who
shrouded in a fair degree of mystery. Take, for example, Montague John
Druitt - who remains one of the most prominent and recurring Ripper
suspects. There is little to recommend Montague John Druitt as a likely
Jack the Ripper candidate but the presumption is that the police, who
took an interest in Druitt, MUST have known something about him that we
don't. In the book that follows we'll take a look at the main
Ripper suspects and attempt to guage who is credible and who isn't. So,
prepare to take a spooky trawl through the fog and dim lamp light to
see if we can make any sense of this most puzzling (not to mention
harrowing) unsolved case. INTRODUCTIONThere
are of course a lot of serial killers who were never caught. In cases
where serial killers were never caught, the most obvious suspects
naturally become people who died or were incarcerated around the time
the murders stopped. The Long Island Killer was the name given to a
serial killer who is believed to have been active in the Long Island
area for twenty years. His last victim was found in 2013. Because this
killer was able (so far at least) to evade capture or identification,
the police believe he might possibly have worked in law enforcement
himself (something which is far from unheard of when it comes to serial
killers). The Long Island Killer is clearly very savvy and clever when
it comes to not leaving any incriminating evidence in his (or her?)
wake. The Axeman of New Orleans was an American serial killer
active in New Orleans, Louisiana, in 1918 and 1919. There were six
people killed and six injured during his bloody spree of violence. The
killer was never identified and seemed to target the local Italian
community. The killer used an axe or razor to kill the victims. The
victims were mostly female but he killed a few men who were unfortunate
enough to be in the houses he had broken into. Sexual sadism was the
most likely motive as the killer never seemed to rob the victims.
Because the victims were Italian-Americans some sort of Mafia link was
suspected but this was never proven. The identity of the killer remains
a mystery. Zodiac was the name given to a killer who operated
in California in the 60s and 70s. The killer, who was never found,
claimed to have killed thirty people. The police still periodically
re-open the case if fresh information comes to light. The Zodiac Killer
targeted couples who were parked up in cars. He would shoot both the
man and woman. This suggested that he was an outcast in society and was
embittered and angered by seeing couples in love. Interestingly, Zodiac
seemed to be something of a weekend killer so probably had a job. The
killer began contacting newspapers in 1969 and identified himself as
Zodiac. He was clearly eager to enjoy his moment in the spotlight. The
killer wrote a number of letters which he said contained codes and
ciphers which - if cracked - would reveal his identity. Although some
of these codes have been cracked though so far they haven't actually
revealed the true identity of the killer.The Monster of
Florence was a killer who murdered around sixteen people in Italy from
1968 to 1985. The killer had an MO very similar to the Zodiac Killer in
America. The Monster of Florence would shoot couples who were sitting
together in a car. The killer sometimes removed the sex organs of his
female victims. The 1999 novel Hannibal was inspired by the Florence
case. The killer was never caught by the Italian police although
theories continue to abound. One such theory is that a satanic cult was
behind the murders. Hammersmith in London was the scene of a
number of murders in 1964 and 1965. The killer became known as Jack the
Stripper because the murder victims were prostitutes. However, despite
a huge police operation, the killer was never found and the murders
remain a mystery. One of the more outlandish and bizarre theories
(which, believe it or not, has even been the basis of a book) is that
the killer was the world champion boxer turned actor Freddie Mills. The
victims were nearly all in their twenties and are believed to have been
killed in private before their bodies were dumped in a public place.
Chief Superintendent John Du Rose was in charge of the investigation
for Scotland Yard and had six-hundred police officers involved in the
search for Jack the Stripper. They set up observation posts in a 24
square mile area of London and questioned thousands of potential
suspects and yet - remarkably - they never found the killer. The
Texarkana Moonlight Murders featured an unknown killer who seemed to
have stepped straight out of a real life horror film. 'Texarkana, a
small town that straddles the state line between Texas and Arkansas, is
also known as The Town That Dreaded Sundown, thanks to the 1976 horror
flick of the same name,' wrote the Line-Up. 'Set in Texarkana and based
loosely on a string of local slayings, the proto-slasher film came out
just two years after The Texas Chain Saw Massacre and Black Christmas,
and two years before Halloween. Yet the true story behind the Texarkana
Moonlight Murders is as chilling as anything seen on the silver
screen—and made all the more unsettling because the case remains
unsolved nearly 70 years later. The mysterious Moonlight Murders rocked
the sleepy southern town of Texarkana in 1946. Police on either side of
the state line struggled to work as one while the killings themselves
possessed the iconic quality of urban legend. Young couples parked at
the end of a lonely country road, savaged after the sun went down.'In
fact, some claim that the infamous campfire tale of lovers who catch a
report of a hook-handed killer on the car radio only to discover a
bloody hook hanging from their back door can be traced to the Texarkana
Moonlight Murders. The killer, described by witnesses as wearing a
white mask or sack with holes cut for eyes, was dubbed the Phantom
Killer or Phantom Slayer—a name that, like so much about the case,
seemed ready-made for drive-in theaters. While the Phantom was on the
loose, Texarkana was like a city under siege. Residents armed
themselves and curfews were set for local businesses. In spite of the
involvement of the Texas Rangers, no conclusive arrest was ever made in
connection with the Moonlight Murders.'Theories spread wildly
about the Phantom Killer's identity. The killer's targeting of couples
and lack of other identifiable motives, such as burglary or revenge,
led many in the area to believe that the killer was some sort of "sex
maniac". Nearly 400 people were arrested in connection with the
killings. Suspects included a University of Arkansas freshman who
committed suicide in 1948, an escaped German prisoner of war, and an
L.A. resident who believed that he may have committed the crimes while
in a coma. Many people believe that local man named Youell
Swinney—arrested in 1947 for auto theft—was the Phantom. His wife
confessed to as much at the time, but by law she could not testify
against her husband. She later repudiated her confession. Swinney
remained in prison as a habitual offender until 1973, and died in 1994,
without ever implicating himself in the murders.'The Atlanta
Ripper was a killer who is believed to have killed around fifteen (and
probably) more women in Atlanta in 1911 and 1912. However, this killer
was never captured or identified. All the victims were young black
women and the killer had a grisly habit of slashing the throats of his
targets. The killer had a rather strange habit too of removing the
clothes of the victim and then stacking them in a neat bundle next to
the body. Emma Lou Sharp, who survived an encounter with the killer,
described him as a tall dark skinned man who wore a black hat. The
killer was very brutal. One victim was nearly decapitated and another
had part of her skull crushed. A coupling pin from a train was used to
bludgeon one victim. It is said that the Ripper cut the heart out of
another victim and left it by the body.The Belize Ripper was an
unidentified Belizean serial killer responsible for the abduction, rape
and murder of five girls in Belize between 1998 and 2000. No one was
ever convicted of these murders. The Belize Ripper suspects included an
American serial killer named Lonnie David Franklin Jr who had
connections to the country. The Butcher of Mons was the name given to a
Belgian serial killer who commited five murders in 1996 and 1997. The
victims (all female) were expertly dismembered and left in plastic bags
by an embankment. The identity of The Butcher of Mons was never
established. In the seventies and eighties the remains of several boys
were found in sewers in the Frankfurt Rhine-Main area of Germany. The
victims were bound and many of them were rent boys or drug users (they
were the usual type of vulnerable victims that serial killers target).
Although they had some suspects the German police were never able to
convict anyone of the sewer murders.The Doodler was the name
given to a serial killer who killed at least five men in San Francisco
in 1974 and 1975. The victims, who were all gay, were usually picked up
in bars. The killer got his name because he would 'doodle' a sketch of
the victim as they chatted in a bar. The victims found this quite
charming and it obviously lulled them into what can only be described
as a false sense of security (to say the least). The killer was
described as an urbane young black man but he was never arrested and to
this day his true identity remains unknown. It is believed that the
police actually questioned a man they suspected of being The Doodler in
1976. This man was never named in public and it seems the police simply
didn't have enough evidence to charge him with anything. As a
consequence, the identity of The Doodler remained an elusive mystery.The
Frankford Slasher was a serial killer who operated in and around the
neighborhood of Frankford in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania from 1985 to
1990. Around nine women were raped and stabbed to death. A man was
convicted for one of these murders but he could not be connected to the
others - which left them to remain a mystery. The Sleepy Hollow Killer
is the name of an unidentified South African rapist and serial killer
responsible for the rapes and murders of at least 13 women around
Pietermaritzburg and the Midlands of KwaZulu-Natal. The Sleepy Hollow
Killer was never caught. The Connecticut River Valley Killer gruesomely
stabbed to death at least seven women in and around Claremont, New
Hampshire and the Connecticut River Valley in the 1980s. The
Connecticut River Valley Killer was also never captured. The
Alphabet Murders are an unsolved series of child murders which occurred
between 1971 and 1973 in Rochester, New York. 'The Alphabet Killer is
considered to be one of the greatest unsolved mysteries as far as crime
is concerned in the United States,' wrote the Greatest Unsolved
Mysteries website. 'The individual that committed what is referred to
as the Alphabet Murders have perplexed law enforcement officials in the
area of Rochester, New York since the year of 1971. Three very young
females were taken by the killer, violently raped, and then murdered
immediately thereafter. What makes this case particularly interesting
when it comes to the investigation is that all the three children had
names in which their first name and their last name had the exact same
initial. 'Each girl’s first and last name started with the
same letter. Each child was ten years old. Each child was discovered in
a city that started with the same letter as their name. Each child was
from a Catholic family. Each child lived in a poverty stricken home.
Each child suffered from either disciplinary and/or academic challenges
at school. Due to the fact that each of the victims of the alphabet
murders had these things in common, it was believed that the killer
likely worked with a social service group. Many even thought that they
could have known the families, or that they worked at the school where
the children attended. While several suspects were interviewed the case
remains “cold”. The alphabet killer may still reside among us.'The
Eastbound Strangler is an unidentified serial killer responsible for
the murders of four women near Atlantic City, New Jersey in 2006.
Despite a police investigation and reward fund appealing for
information, the killer has yet to be captured. The I-70 killer is an
unidentified American serial killer who is known to have killed six
store clerks in the Midwest in the spring of 1992. The victims were
shot and had their stores robbed. Although the police were able to use
eyewitnesses to get a sense of what the killer looked like no one was
ever convicted of the murders. The Saw-Killer of Hanover was
responsible for four murders in Germany in the 1970s. The victims
usually had their bodies sawn in half or their limbs cut off. However,
none of the victims could be identified and this made capturing the
killer even more difficult. Although similar grisly murders have
occasionally happened in Germany in later decades no one has ever been
connected to the 1970s killings or convicted for the crimes.The
Skid Row Stabber is an unidentified American serial killer responsible
for the murders of 11 people in the Los Angeles neighborhood known as
Skid Row in the 1970s. The victims were (as the name implies) stabbed
to death. Bobby Joe Maxwell was originally convicted of the crimes but
later evidence cast doubt on this. As a consequence, The Skid Row
Stabber might still be at large. The Denver Strangler was an
unidentified serial killer operating in Denver, Colorado from 1894 to
1903. The Strangler killed three prostitutes but no one was ever
convicted of the crimes. The Redhead Murders was a case where around
ten women were killed between 1978 and 1992 in Tennessee, Arkansas,
Kentucky, Mississippi, Pennsylvania, and West Virginia. The common link
was that the victims all had red hair. The killer responsible for the
Redhead Murders has yet to be caught. The Cleveland Torso
Murderer is one of the grisliest serial killers never captured. 'What’s
more terrifying than a serial killer?' wrote Film Daily. 'One that was
never, ever caught. In the history of serial killers in the US, it’s
amazing that the Cleveland Torso Murderer is not often talked about.
From 1935-38, this unknown killer terrorized the city of Cleveland,
targeting those in vulnerable circumstances, and left between 12-20
people dead. Even outsmarted famed lawman Eliot Ness, leaving a black
mark on his distinguished record. The Murderer was very deliberate in
picking his victims. They were either working poor, drifters, or
homeless. The Murderer did not show gender preference toward his
victims. He killed both men and women. The bodies always ended up the
same way: beheaded, dismembered, and disposed of. A lot of the male
victims were castrated as well. In addition, some of the victims showed
signs of a chemical treatment being applied to the bodies. This was
still a time when forensic science was in a relative infancy, so not a
lot could be gleaned from that. Even worse, the Murderer disposed of
the bodies well. Many of his victims weren’t found until some time
after their deaths had passed. 'Like Jack the Ripper, the
Cleveland Torso Murderer had canonical victims and non-canonical but
likely victims. There are 12 canonical murders associated with the
Murderer, most of them have never been identified. In addition to the
canonical murders, police believe that the killer likely had 20 victims
in total. There are two arrests in the case of the Cleveland Torso
Murderer. One of the suspects arrested is believed to be more likely
than the other. Or, at least, Ness believed that this suspect, Dr.
Francis Sweeney, was the Murderer. Sweeney was a medical soldier in
WWI, where he performed field amputations. The second arrest goes to
Frank Dolezal, who had a connection to the eighth victim Florence
Polillo. Police were desperate for arrest. So they arrest Dolezal, beat
a confession out of him (which he retracted), and, then, Dolezal
mysteriously died while in custody. He was officially cleared decades
later. The final theory associated with the case is that, like Jack the
Ripper, the Cleveland Torso Murderer is actually multiple killers, who
heard about the deaths and copied each other in order to make it look
like a serial killer.'The Freeway Phantom was serial killer who
was active in Washington, D.C. from April 1971 through to September
1972. The Phantom strangled, raped, and killed six women but he was
never caught. The Flat-Tire murders were five connected, unsolved
murders in Dade County, Florida in 1975. The killer in the Flat-Tire
murders is believed to have let air out of his victims cars and then
offered them assistance on the road before killing them. These were
brutal murders (some of the victims were injured so badly they couldn't
be identified) and the killer was clearly very cunning. Ted Bundy is
sometimes cited as a possible suspect in the Flat-Tire murders although
he denied this accusation. Bible John is an unidentified
serial killer who is believed to have murdered three young women
between 1968 and 1969 in Glasgow. Bible John is believed to have met
the victims at the Barrowland Ballroom. Some criminologists believe
that the convicted murderer Peter Tobin might have been Bible John.
There are many more mysterious serial killers who were never captured.
The most famous of all of these is of course Jack the Ripper.One
of the first books inspired by Jack the Ripper was The Mystery of Jack
the Ripper by Leonard Matters. The book suggested that the Ripper was a
doctor who became enraged after his son was killed by a dose of
syphilis he'd caught from a prostitute. In 1923, William Tufnell LeQuex
wrote a book in which he suggested Jack the Ripper was a Russian doctor
involved in a Czarist plot to murder women in London and make the
British police and establishment seem weak and ineffective. There
have been endless Jack the Ripper books proposing all manner of
theories (some outlandish and long since debunked and others plausible
and interesting) and all manner of suspects. While some of the suspects
floated are plainly ridiculous (Dr Barnardo, John Merrick etc) there
are many fascinating realistic Ripper suspects who remain worthy of
investigation. The thing is though that they can't ALL have been Jack
the Ripper. This means that the vast majority of Ripper suspects are
actually red herrings. Sifting through them all to find the most likely
suspect is far from easy and a task that has kept true crime and
detective buffs busy for over a hundred years. During the
search for Jack the Ripper, the police investigated a number of medical
students because of the theory that the killer had some medical
knowledge. The notion that the killer was a crazy medical student was
actually quite popular in police circles for a time. However, this
angle turned up no credible leads or suspects. A recent FBI profile of
Jack the Ripper dismissed the theory that the Ripper had professional
medical knowledge. They judged him to be a shabby loner and not someone
of high society or any standing. This has been questioned though
because many believe the Ripper must have been quite urbane and
respectable because how else could he have earned the trust of his
victims? Prostitutes in Victorian London were streetwise. If they
suspected a client was dangerous or unhinged they wouldn't allow
themselves to be alone with them. Many believe that Jack the
Ripper was much more likely to have been a butcher than someone with
medical knowledge. We simply don't know for sure though. One of the
reasons why there were so few eye (and ear!) witnesses to Jack the
Ripper's murders is that sewage at that time was left to fester in the
street and cellars. People usually closed their windows to block out
the stench. The eyewitness accounts of the Ripper never led an
identification which unveiled the killer. As for the letters allegedly
written by the Ripper, well, opinion varies on whether or not any of
them were actually from the killer. Scotland Yard had to deal with an
awful lot of hoaxers during the Ripper case. There were even numerous
men who confessed to being the Ripper but were then proven to have
nothing whatsoever to do with the murders. One of the problems
with Jack the Ripper is that there isn't even a clear consensus on what
type of serial killer he was. It is often said that serial killers fall
into four distinct groups. Visionary, Mission-oriented, Hedonistic and
Power/Control. Visionary serial killers are the ones who, when
captured, say that voices in their head told them to do it. They
believe they had some divine or mystical mission to murder people.
Peter Sutcliffe (aka The Yorkshire Ripper) was supposedly an example of
this type of killer. Sutcliffe (who suffered from paranoid
schizophrenia - though there is some serious doubt about this) said
that God told him to kill prostitutes. Another example of a
Visionary serial killer would be Herbert Mullin - who killed thirteen
people in California from 1972 to 1973. Mullin had paranoid
schizophrenia and believed that he had to murder people as part of a
blood sacrifice to prevent earthquakes from happening in California. He
started to hear voices in his head which told him the only way to
prevent earthquakes was human sacrifice. A Mission-oriented serial
killer will target one specific type of victim. These killers have a
desire to punish and eliminate one specific section of society. An
example of this type of killer would be Sergei Ryakhovsky. Ryakhovsky
is known as The Balashikha Ripper. He killed at least eighteen people
in the Moscow area between 1988 and 1993. Ryakhovsky said his mission
was to cleanse society of homosexuals and prostitutes. One might argue
that Jack the Ripper had something in common with Ryakhovsky.Another
Mission-oriented serial killer would be Steve Wright. Wright became
known as The Suffolk Strangler after he murdered five female
prostitutes in eastern England in 2006. The source of his descent
into madness seems to have been his alcohol and gambling addictions -
which left him bankrupt and suicidal. Steve Wright's victims were all
prostitutes. The youngest was only sixteen. He killed the five women in
only five days - a rate which made him a prolific killer by any
standards. Luckily, he was caught quite soon into his killing spree.
Wright clearly had a grudge against sex workers and wanted to kill as
many as possible. Jack the Ripper, like Wright, was evidently someone
on his own warped mission too.