1,99 €
Niedrigster Preis in 30 Tagen: 1,99 €
Niedrigster Preis in 30 Tagen: 1,99 €
Mehr erfahren.
- Herausgeber: Booksell-Verlag
- Kategorie: Geisteswissenschaft
- Sprache: Englisch
The Note-Books of Samuel Butler is an intriguing compilation that offers profound insights into Butler's intellectual musings and philosophical reflections on a diverse range of subjects including art, science, and society. The literary style is characterized by Butler'Äôs sharp wit and keen observational prowess, often presented in the form of aphorisms and succinct commentary, which invites readers to engage critically with his thoughts. This collection acts as both an autobiographical window into the mind of a 19th-century Victorian intellectual and a broader commentary on his contemporary society, revealing the tensions between tradition and modernity that permeate his work. Samuel Butler was a polymath: a novelist, essayist, and social critic known for his iconoclastic ideas, especially towards Darwinism and Victorian values. His discontent with societal norms and traditional beliefs, stemming from his own unique experiences'Äîincluding his stay in New Zealand'Äîshaped his unconventional worldview. These influences are palpable in his note-books, as he navigates both personal introspection and societal critique, melding philosophies and experiences into a rich tapestry of thought. This illuminating collection is highly recommended for readers interested in the interplay of art, philosophy, and social critique during the Victorian era. Butler's notes not only reflect his creative genius but also serve as a thought-provoking commentary that remains relevant in today'Äôs conversations about individualism and societal expectations.
Das E-Book können Sie in Legimi-Apps oder einer beliebigen App lesen, die das folgende Format unterstützen:
Veröffentlichungsjahr: 2019
Ähnliche
The Note-Books of Samuel Butler
Table of Contents
Introduction
A restless, skeptical mind turns everyday observation into a testing ground for art, science, and belief. The Note-Books of Samuel Butler gathers the author’s private jottings into a mosaic of thought that reveals his distinctive blend of candor, irony, and intellectual independence. Known for his satirical fiction and incisive essays, Butler records the seeds of arguments and intuitions that animated his published work, while also registering the passing spark of daily insight. The result is not a narrative but a living conversation with himself and, by extension, with the reader—inquiring, provisional, and continually alert to the ways ideas grow, collide, and refine one another.
This volume belongs to the tradition of literary notebooks and commonplace books—nonfiction that preserves aphorisms, sketches, and brief reflections rather than sustained treatises. Compiled from Butler’s papers and published after his death, it was assembled and edited by his close associate Henry Festing Jones in the early twentieth century. The entries arise from the intellectual climate of the later nineteenth century, when debates about evolution, biblical criticism, aesthetics, and social convention were especially alive. Without requiring specialist knowledge, the book situates readers near the workshop of Butler’s mind, where reading, observation, and experiment supply raw material for lucid, skeptical appraisal.
Readers encounter an array of short entries, marginalia-like notes, and compact essays that move swiftly between topics while maintaining a coherent temperament. Butler’s voice is plainspoken yet sharp, committed to clear statement over ornament, and enlivened by humor that can be genial or cutting. The mood alternates between playful contrarianism and patient analysis, with an eye for the telling example that brings an abstract point into focus. Because the pieces are concise, the experience invites browsing as much as linear reading, rewarding pauses for reflection. The texture is cumulative: recurring concerns reappear from new angles, encouraging readers to trace patterns rather than chase conclusions.
At the heart of these pages are themes that preoccupied Butler throughout his career: the making and judging of art; the authority of scientific and religious explanations; the ethics of everyday conduct; and the relationship between originality, tradition, and influence. He tests accepted ideas against common sense and lived experience, pushing back against jargon and cant. The notebooks frequently consider how language shapes thought, how habit can dull perception, and how skepticism need not preclude sympathy. Unafraid of paradox, Butler delights in formulations that unsettle reflex opinion, not to shock but to clear ground for a steadier view. The emphasis is practical: how to think well, and thus how to live better.
For contemporary readers, the book’s relevance lies in its model of disciplined independence. Butler charts a path between naïve certainty and paralyzing doubt, asking how one might question prevailing orthodoxies without devolving into mere contrariness. His approach rewards curiosity across boundaries, drawing connections among literature, biology, music, and moral philosophy. In an era saturated with data and assertion, the notebooks exemplify a habit of mind that favors testing claims against observation, acknowledging limits, and revising with good humor. The tone never insists on final answers; it invites readers to keep the conversation going, to use his notes as prompts for their own inquiries.
The volume also illuminates Butler’s larger body of work. Readers familiar with Erewhon and The Way of All Flesh will recognize concerns that resonate across genres—satire sharpened by ethical seriousness, distrust of pious pretenses, and fascination with how institutions shape individuals. Those new to Butler will find an accessible entrance to his thought, unencumbered by plot and guided by a steady editorial hand that presents his reflections without academic scaffolding. The notebooks show ideas at various stages—germs, sketches, and near-finished formulations—offering both a record of process and a self-portrait in fragments. They reveal continuity without requiring biographical knowledge to appreciate their force.
To open these notebooks is to sit beside a candid, unsparing, and often entertaining companion who takes thinking as a daily craft. The entries invite agreement, dissent, and, most of all, further thought, making the book a resource to revisit rather than consume once. Its durability comes from the balance it strikes: serious without solemnity, skeptical without cynicism, and engaged without system-building. Whether dipped into at random or read in steady intervals, it offers the stimulus of a mind that refuses easy answers while seeking workable truths. In presenting that example, it speaks across periods, encouraging a reader’s own independence of judgment.
Synopsis (Selection)
The Note-Books of Samuel Butler is a posthumous compilation of short entries, aphorisms, and memoranda that Butler recorded across many years. Presented without a continuous narrative, the volume groups his observations by recurring interests while preserving the informal tone of a working notebook. Readers encounter brief reflections, anecdotes, and drafted formulations that often point back to his published books. The arrangement emphasizes range over completeness, moving from practical counsel on craft to inquiries into art, religion, science, and classical literature. A concise editorial framing clarifies that the pieces are occasional and exploratory, inviting attention to Butler’s method as much as to his conclusions.
The opening movement concentrates on writing and bookmaking, where Butler sets out principles of composition, revision, and the relation between authors and readers. He addresses the economy of words, the usefulness of commonplace books, and the hazards of over-elaboration. He weighs originality against adaptation, noting how ideas migrate and improve through use. Remarks on reviewers, publishers, and the marketplace outline the contingencies of literary success and the tact required to steer through them. Throughout, he treats style as a practical tool shaped by habit and audience, favoring clarity, apt analogy, and steady work over theory for its own sake.
From craft, the notebooks turn to aesthetics, considering painting, sculpture, and architecture alongside the conditions that sustain them. Butler emphasizes workmanship, continuity with tradition, and the everyday uses of art. He prefers the test of lived experience to abstract systems, noting how conventions become serviceable through repeated practice. Remarks on Renaissance masters sit beside comments on contemporary exhibition culture, the role of patrons, and the difficulties of judging novelty. He frequently returns to the claim that art thrives where it is wanted for definite ends, and that humor and plainness help prevent solemnity from hardening into mannerism.
Butler’s attention to the arts extends to music, poetry, and the stage, with compact notes on composition, performance, and reception. He considers melody and counterpoint as forms of memory made audible, and he links effective form to intelligibility for listeners and readers. Brief remarks on translation propose fidelity to sense and spirit over literalism, treating form as a vehicle rather than a cage. He notes how conventions in verse and drama enable rather than confine, provided they are used with purpose. These entries continue his preference for utility and intelligibility, aligning artistic success with communicable structure and disciplined ease.
Religious and ethical reflections follow, surveying doctrine, worship, and conduct with attention to their social effects. Butler distinguishes personal integrity from adherence to systems, urging that belief be judged by outcomes in behavior. He treats the Bible as literature as well as tradition, considering how texts acquire authority and how institutions maintain it. He records reservations about dogma while allowing for the consolations of ritual and community. Notes on sincerity, conscience, and tolerance emphasize habits formed in daily practice rather than abstract profession. The section’s recurring thread is the testing of claims by experience and usefulness.
A substantial portion engages science, particularly evolution, heredity, and mind. Butler summarizes the lines of thought developed in his books Life and Habit, Evolution, Old and New, and Unconscious Memory, proposing that organisms act through inherited memory and acquired habit. He questions the sufficiency of natural selection alone, reopening earlier ideas of purposive adaptation while keeping the discussion within observable processes. Metaphors of memory, use, and intention help him connect physiology with behavior without invoking fixed metaphysical systems. The notes map a program: study life by its self-maintaining routines, treat intelligence as continuous with habit, and explain change through accumulated practice.
Classical studies appear next, particularly Homer. Butler outlines his approach to the Iliad and the Odyssey, emphasizing internal evidence, geography, and practical considerations of authorship and audience. He advances the view that the Odyssey reflects a specific landscape and social setting, and he explores translation principles aimed at rendering Homer intelligible and direct in English. He reports on the reception of these ideas and notes the resistance of established scholarship to revision. The entries present a method—read the text as a coherent artifact shaped by use and circumstance—consistent with his broader preference for common-sense inference over abstraction.
The notebooks then range across society, money, education, and travel, gathering maxims and situational observations. Butler comments on work, thrift, and risk; on law and administration; and on the ways institutions attract or repel talent. He records impressions from Italy, New Zealand, and the Alps, connecting place to art, custom, and belief. Notes on friendship, reputation, and the press stress steady conduct over display. Advice on health, small economies, and daily routine reinforces his theme that character consolidates through repeated acts. The miscellany illustrates his method: accumulate particulars, note convergences, and extract guidance fit for ordinary use.
Closing entries address aging, illness, and death alongside reflections on the notebook form itself. Butler acknowledges inconsistency and revision as signs of ongoing inquiry, not defects to be concealed. He returns to working principles—sift experience, prefer the serviceable to the showy, and keep hypotheses answerable to facts. The overarching message is coherence through habit: art, morals, and knowledge mature by practice and memory rather than sudden revelation. The collection’s final effect is composite rather than conclusive, presenting a durable record of problems, trials, and provisional solutions that together show how Butler thought and the kind of usefulness he sought in thinking.
Historical Context
Samuel Butler’s Note-Books were compiled from entries written chiefly between the 1860s and his death in 1902, then edited by Henry Festing Jones and published in London in 1912. The intellectual climate is late Victorian and early Edwardian Britain: imperial, urbanizing, and disputatious in religion and science. Butler lived and worked largely in London’s legal Inns (Clifford’s Inn; later Staple Inn), but his reflections were shaped by wide travel in New Zealand, northern Italy, and Sicily. The period saw railways knit Britain and the Continent, newspapers multiply audiences, and new sciences challenge inherited certainties. His notes thus emerge from a world balancing industrial modernity, Anglican establishment authority, and post-Darwinian debate.
Industrialization framed Butler’s lifetime. The Great Exhibition of 1851 at the Crystal Palace displayed British manufacturing prowess; railways boomed from the 1840s, and the world’s first underground railway opened in London in 1863. Factories, telegraphy, and mechanized workshops reoriented labor and social relations, while London’s population surged past three million by the 1860s. In June 1863 Butler published “Darwin among the Machines” in the Christchurch Press, speculating that machines might evolve—an idea born of an age of accelerating mechanical complexity. The Note-Books revisit these anxieties and curiosities, treating machinery, technique, and habit as social facts that alter human memory, routine, and moral expectations in an industrial metropolis.
British settler colonialism in New Zealand provided formative experience. After the Treaty of Waitangi (1840) and the Canterbury Association’s Anglican colony (founded 1848 by Edward Gibbon Wakefield and John Robert Godley), Butler arrived at Lyttelton in 1859. He purchased the Mesopotamia sheep run on the upper Rangitata River in 1860 and sold it profitably in 1864. The pastoral frontier around the Southern Alps demanded improvisation, contracts, and labor management within a rapidly expanding colonial economy. The Note-Books draw upon this milieu to observe class fluidity, religious pragmatism, and property as a social institution. Butler’s colonial years tempered his view of English decorum and fed his later skepticism toward metropolitan moralizing.
The publication of Charles Darwin’s On the Origin of Species (1859) and The Descent of Man (1871) reconfigured Victorian intellectual life, provoking the famous 1860 Oxford debate between T. H. Huxley and Bishop Samuel Wilberforce. By the 1870s, “scientific naturalism” (Huxley, Joseph Dalton Hooker, John Tyndall) had strong institutional sway. Butler, although initially intrigued, grew critical of natural selection as a complete explanation. He insisted on predecessors—Erasmus Darwin’s Zoonomia (1794–1796) and Jean-Baptiste Lamarck’s Philosophie zoologique (1809)—and sought to restore purpose and memory to biology. The Note-Books preserve his historical sense of scientific lineage and register his resistance to a purely mechanistic, impersonal evolution.
Between 1878 and 1887 Butler advanced an alternative evolutionary vocabulary. In Life and Habit (1878), Evolution, Old and New (1879), Unconscious Memory (1880), and Luck, or Cunning, as the Main Means of Organic Modification? (1887), he developed a theory that organisms inherit “habit” and that memory operates as a biological function. He drew upon Ewald Hering’s 1870 Prague address, Über das Gedächtnis, proposing memory as a general property of organized matter. These arguments, frequently rehearsed in the Note-Books, fused biology with everyday observation, framing heredity in terms of use, recollection, and intention. Butler’s aphorisms link empirical minutiae to large claims about purpose in nature, expressly countering late-Victorian reductions of life to blind mechanism.
Butler’s disputes with the Darwinian establishment were public and protracted. He accused Charles and Francis Darwin, and George John Romanes, of inadequate acknowledgment of predecessors and of misrepresenting his views; exchanges in The Athenaeum (notably 1880–1882) reveal the period’s sharp contests over priority and theory. The X Club’s influence (founded 1864 by Huxley and allies) exemplified the consolidation of scientific authority through journals, societies, and patronage. The Note-Books record Butler’s grievances and document the sociology of Victorian science—how reputations, reviews, and editorial boards mediated acceptance. They also show his enduring attempt to reconcile purposive life with evolutionary change, a discord that defined the era’s cultural politics of knowledge.
Continental travel, especially in Italy, anchored Butler’s historical and religious reflections. After Italian unification (Kingdom of Italy proclaimed 1861; Rome annexed 1870), he roamed Piedmont and Canton Ticino, visiting sanctuaries such as Oropa and Varallo; Alps and Sanctuaries appeared in 1881. In the 1890s he turned to Sicily (Trapani, Mount Eryx/Erice, the Aegadian Islands), proposing in The Authoress of the Odyssey (1897) that a young Sicilian woman composed the poem—an audacious thesis informed by local topography. Schliemann’s excavations at Hisarlik (from 1870) and Mycenae (1876) energized Homeric debates. The Note-Books distill these excursions, juxtaposing Catholic ritual, post-Risorgimento civic life, and classical archaeology as living history.
The Note-Books operate as a social and political critique of late-Victorian Britain. Butler exposes clerical authority and the Anglican household as engines of conformity, shaped by the Church’s social power and public-school discipline. He interrogates class pretensions forged by industrial wealth and colonial capital, observing how ownership and respectability license moral double standards. Against triumphant naturalism, he challenges scientific institutions for gatekeeping and for neglecting intellectual ancestry. His colonial and Italian vignettes contrast metropolitan dogma with pragmatic, local ethics. The aphorisms advocate intellectual independence, argue for responsibility within evolution, and scrutinize progress, revealing the tensions of an age torn between inherited hierarchies and modern, mass-mediated expertise.
