Weak Signals for Strategic Intelligence E-Book

Humbert Lesca

• Herausgeber: John Wiley & Sons
• Kategorie: Wissenschaft und neue Technologien
• Sprache: Englisch

Seitenzahl: 306

Veröffentlichungsjahr: 2013

Beschreibung

The expression: "We did not see it coming!" has often been heard in recent years from decision makers at the highest levels of responsibility in the private and public sectors. Yet there were actually early (warning) signals, but they were often ignored or not used due to a lack of appropriate methodology. To avoid such blind spots, this book provides answers to the question "how to anticipate". The concept of a "weak signal" is at the heart of the proposed methods. After presenting examples of this concept, the authors provide original and validated answers to questions of feasibility: How to recognize a weak signal? How to exploit it? Numerous applications are presented.

Leseprobe

Table of Contents

Introduction

Chapter 1. Concepts, Issues and Hypotheses

1.1. Introduction: governance and radar

1.2. The organization’s environment and its governance through a “storm”

1.3. Anticipation (act of looking forward)

1.4. Anticipative information: two types

1.5. Weak signals

1.6. Detecting weak signals

1.7. Interpreting, amplifying and exploiting weak signals to support strategic decision making

1.8. Puzzle® method for the operationalization of CCM

1.9. Global VASIC process for detecting, recognizing and utilizing weak signals

1.10. Conclusion

Chapter 2. Detecting, Recognizing and Corroborating a Weak Signal: Applications

2.1. Recognition of a weak signal: examples

2.2. Making a new weak signal reliable

2.3. Conclusion

Chapter 3. Utilization of Weak Signals, Collective Creation of Meaning: Applications

3.1. The Roger case: should we fear this new entrant to our industry? (the banking sector)

3.2. The case for “valorizing CO2 as a commodity”: a preliminary study for the selection of a new strategic direction

3.3. The Danone case. The ministry is worried: are there signs showing that companies will destroy jobs over the next two years? Could Danone leave France?

3.4. The Opel case: initiating collective transversal intelligence to aid strategic decision-making

3.5. Conclusion

Chapter 4. Preparation of Weak Signals for Sessions in Collective Creation of Meaning: Applications

4.1. Introduction: two starting situations

4.2. The Roger case (continued): how are the news briefs used in the Roger CCM session prepared?

4.3. CO2 valorization case: automatic search for “news briefs”

4.4. The Danone case: preparation of the weak signals

4.5. Software modules for assisting in the automatic search for news briefs

4.6. Conclusion

Conclusion

Glossary

Bibliography

Index

First published 2011 in Great Britain and the United States by ISTE Ltd and John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Adapted and updated from Les signaux faibles et la veille anticipative pour les décideurs published 2011 in France by Hermes Science/Lavoisier © Lavoisier 2011

Apart from any fair dealing for the purposes of research or private study, or criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, this publication may only be reproduced, stored or transmitted, in any form or by any means, with the prior permission in writing of the publishers, or in the case of reprographic reproduction in accordance with the terms and licenses issued by the CLA. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside these terms should be sent to the publishers at the undermentioned address:

ISTE Ltd27-37 St George’s RoadLondon SW19 4EUUK

John Wiley & Sons, Inc.111 River StreetHoboken, NJ 07030USA

www.iste.co.uk

www.wiley.com

© ISTE Ltd 2011

The rights of Humbert Lesca & Nicolas Lesca to be identified as the authors of this work have been asserted by them in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

Weak signals for strategic intelligence : anticipation tool for managers / Humbert Lesca, Nicolas Lesca.

p. cm.

Adaption and rev. of: Les signaux faibles et la veille anticipative pour les decideurs. 2011.

Includes bibliographical references and index.

ISBN 978-1-84821-318-0

1. Strategic planning. 2. Management. I. Lesca, Nicolas. II. Lesca, Humbert. III. Title.

HD30.28.L457 2011

658.4’72--dc23

2011031444

British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data

A CIP record for this book is available from the British Library

ISBN 978-1-84821-318-0

Introduction

Why take an interest in weak signals? Weak signals are a means of helping managers of businesses (or other organizations) anticipate, in order to make strategic decisions in the context of a turbulent environment that requires them to “see things coming early enough”. Numerous recent examples in the world of industry and finance, as well as in the public sector, have shown that this ambitious objective is more pressing than ever, given the characteristics of the economic, technological, social, and political environment. The central concept is that of a “weak signal”, the first concrete example of which is provided at the very beginning of this book.

How should we go about it? A concept is not sufficient to act; it is not operational. This book chiefly proposes actionable knowledge, that is, a method and some tools to search for, identify, and interpret weak signals. These were gradually constructed within the scientific context of CNRS and university research. They have been applied and validated in the field on numerous occasions.

NOTE.– The phrase “weak signal” has been retained for historical reasons; we are actually dealing with early warning signals, harbingers of changes that matter to the decision-maker.

I.1. Introductory example: a surprising encounter on the corner of an alley: Tata

The following is narrated by A, a sales engineer employed by the German car manufacturer X, who is passing through Cuneo (Italy).

Cuneo is a city in Piedmont of which few foreigners have heard, including non-Piedmontese Italians. Still, this city and its province are rather wealthy: agriculture, viticulture/enology, many SMEs in various industries. It is certainly not seen as a “showcase” by Italians or foreigners. And yet...

I.1.1. Sales engineer A, on a July 2006 morning

“Departing entirely from habit, I go through one of Cuneo’s side streets, in a rather remote district, to go and visit someone who has been hospitalized in that neighborhood’s hospital. As I am about to cross the street and enter the hospital, a shop sign catches my eye, a Tata sign.

Surprised, I cross the street again to have a closer look at it. It is a Tata car dealership. I cannot resist going in to look around. The premises are quite small, with three cars on show. The attendant looks at me and smiles politely.

I ask:

– “Have you been here for long?”

– “It’ll be a year in a few days.”

I go out of the shop and, finally, into the hospital opposite. My mind is quite intrigued.

I remember, as any European very well knows, that Fiat has been on the brink of economic disaster, arguably in a worse situation than its European peers/competitors.

On leaving the hospital, I deliberately pass through the Cuneo business park in search of a Fiat dealer. I go in and, after a short while, I ask the store manager whether he is aware of the Tata brand being present in the city:

– “Yes”, he replies.

– “That’s a new competitor for you, right?”

– “Yes, but we’re not overly worried. Tata is unknown to Italians. In fact, I doubt that shop will survive much longer, especially in that location!”

– “Didn’t the management at Fiat express any concern?”

– “No, neither concern nor anything else. They have other fish to fry.”

I.1.2. Salesman C (from the German car manufacturer X), late August

Having had a chat with A on a train during August, C declares: “I know someone in Turin who works for Fiat. I’ll ask him about Tata, with caution … he holds a high-ranking position.”

A few days later, C telephones A: “I spoke to my pal in Turin. He was a bit embarrassed with my question, and then he said that Fiat was aware of Tata’s presence in Cuneo (Fiat’s foremost province) and that it was actually a good thing, which Fiat wished for. But he asked me not to talk about it, and he wouldn’t say any more.”

I.1.3. Financial executive B (an employee of the German car manufacturer X), some four months later

“I read in my daily paper that Fiat is doing better now, toward the end of 2006.

In an interview excerpt, Sergio Marchionne, the head of Fiat’s automobile arm, said in reply to a journalist’s query that Fiat favors a strategy of ad hoc alliances with businesses that are likely to share specific competences which Fiat lacks. He mentioned Ford by way of example.”

I.1.4. Post scriptum

December 2006

Fiat and Tata Motors announced in sequence a few months later, namely in December 2006, the setting up of their jointly owned subsidiary, which represents a 665 million euro investment (source: Les Echos, 12/15/2006, p. 18).

August 2010

Tata Motors discloses its wish to reinforce its alliance with Fiat in the field of trucks as well as automobiles (source: La Stampa, 08/13/2010, p. 25).

I.2. Conclusion

Through this introductory example, we have pursued the following objectives, with regard to the reader:

– to arouse the reader’s interest in this book;

– to offer an intuitive approach to the concepts of anticipative information and weak signal;

– to provide an example of what will hereinafter be referred to as “information originating from field people”.

Chapter 1

Concepts, Issues and Hypotheses

1.1. Introduction: governance and radar

Let us begin with a metaphor, namely the radar, and its likeness, that is, the detection of weak signals by the enterprise.

Generally speaking, governance denotes the art of governing, whether it is a country, a company (corporate governance) or indeed a ship [LES 08a]. In the latter, the main instrument of governance happens to be the rudder. In the following, we shall be comparing the business to a ship in order to introduce the concept of a weak signal in the most illustrative way possible, as that concept constitutes the core of this book. Let it be noted that, in the remainder of the text, we will use the word enterprise in a very general sense. It will refer to all forms of organization, including industrial, commercial or service companies; government bodies (ministries, etc.); local authorities; public bodies (for example Family Allowances Funds), etc. [LES 02b]. The examples given originate from research projects performed by our team in those different types of organizations.

1.1.1. Steering the ship

The principal objective assigned to the ships captain is to accomplish the mission assigned to him/her and to reach the destination safely. This has always been and still remains true. In order to fulfill that objective, the ship and its crew need a good captain. A good captain possesses human qualities and technical competences suitable to his/her role. Such human qualities include, among others, humility (the opposite of arrogance), the ability to scrutinize his/her environment, including but not limited to the sea, also to listen to crew members, to exercise curiosity, vigilance, and scanning, to demonstrate anticipation and responsiveness. However, the captain is not the only one involved in enabling the ship to accomplish its mission. So is the ships owner. Is he/she prepared to ensure that the ship is in good condition and properly provided with suitable instruments? Let us now venture a metaphor and attempt an analogy with the enterprise.