In the Shadow of Arnhem E-Book

Ken Tout

• Herausgeber: The History Press
• Kategorie: Geisteswissenschaft
• Sprache: Englisch

Veröffentlichungsjahr: 2016

Beschreibung

The Battle of Arnhem in September 1944 has been much publicised, with its extraordinary parachute drop and gallant defence by Frost's few men of the bridge at Arnhem. Although the campaign came close to success, its relative failure left the Allies trapped within a thirty-mile stretch of road. The Arnhem debacle saw vast stretches of Holland to the left and right of the salient occupied by enemy forces. These areas of Holland, criss-crossed by unfordable rivers and closely populated by small villages, had to be cleared by Allied troops in platoon or company strength, fighting in tight situations against bitter skilled resistance. There was none of the awesome and inspirational massing of troops seen in the battle of Normandy, for Arnhem itself. Interweaving his engaging narrative style with the eyewitness accounts and personal reminiscences of British, Canadian and Polish troops, Ken Tout reveals how these men performed their heroic deeds. They suffered and died in unheralded, largely forgotten minor skirmishes, but on a scale far exceeding the casualties of the immediate assault on Arnhem. They deserve to be remembered. This is their story.

Leseprobe

IN THE SHADOW OFARNHEM

IN THE SHADOW OFARNHEM

THE BATTLE FOR THE LOWER

MAAS, SEPTEMBER–NOVEMBER 1944

KEN TOUT

First published in 2003

This edition first published in 2009

The History Press

The Mill, Brimscombe Port

Stroud, Gloucestershire, GL5 2QG

www.thehistorypress.co.uk

This ebook edition first published in 2016

All rights reserved

© Ken Tout, 2003, 2009

The right of Ken Tout, to be identified as the Author of this work has been asserted in accordance with the Copyrights, Designs and Patents Act 1988.

This ebook is copyright material and must not be copied, reproduced, transferred, distributed, leased, licensed or publicly performed or used in any way except as specifically permitted in writing by the publishers, as allowed under the terms and conditions under which it was purchased or as strictly permitted by applicable copyright law. Any unauthorised distribution or use of this text may be a direct infringement of the author’s and publisher’s rights, and those responsible may be liable in law accordingly.

EPUB ISBN 978 0 7509 5132 6

Typesetting and origination by The History Press

eBook converted by Geethik Technologies

To those who were killed or deprived of a normal life in costly but unsung battles back down the Arnhem road. The wider story of their sacrifices and heroism has been neglected because of popular concentration on the equally heroic but unfortunate epic of the ‘bridge too far’ at Arnhem.

Contents

List of Illustrations

Acknowledgements

Maps

1. Beggary and Bravery

2. Mad Tuesday and Black Friday

3. Arnhem – the Sore Thumb

4. Antwerp: the Generals Forgot

5. A Pocket of Small Change

6. Chill Ghost of Autumn

7. A Dutch Krakatoa

8. Wet! Wetter!! Wettest!!!

9. More Arrows on the Map

10. Massing towards the Maas

11. Guns towards the Fatherland

12. Reflections on the Water

Glossary

Notes and References

Bibliography

List of Illustrations

1.

Jack Harper VC.

2.

The memorial to Jack Harper at Hatfield Woodhouse.

3.

The paupers’ dormitories at Depôt de Mendicité (1940s).

4.

The vital 2-in mortars: crew man drops bomb on to striking pin in the tube.

5.

Westkapelle civilians being issued with coupons for wooden clogs under German occupation.

6.

Infantry cross an open polder which is easily covered by enemy m-gs; canal is impassable for tanks.

7.

Main roads in 1944 were not constructed for two-way armoured traffic, a hazard of the Arnhem Road.

8.

Ammunition exploding from burning vehicle blocking the single Arnhem Road.

9.

FM Walter Model and Maj Gen Walter Bruns of the reconstituted 89th Division destroyed in Normandy.

10.

An escaping RAF pilot, Eugene Haveley, has a Resistance haircut.

11.

Numbers of prisoners were taken around Antwerp, and the lions’ cages at the zoo had to be used as temporary lodgings.

12.

An anonymous nurse representing many women who served in danger, including George Blackburn’s ‘ambulancemen’.

13.

Cpl Cliff Brown leads the Lincs & Wellands into Eeklo.

14.

A Buffalo, ‘an iron box with an outboard engine’, crosses the river ferrying about twenty men.

15.

The impossibility of tank manoeuvre amid flooded polders and rain-saturated embankments (Shermans queuing).

16.

Canada’s Lt Gen Guy G. Simonds, one of the youngest and most brilliant of Allied generals, decided to sink the island.

17.

The crew and ground staff of Lancaster ED 888 (576 Sqn).

18.

P/O Vernon Wilkes looks out through the bomb sight of his Lancaster.

19.

Spitfire PL 850 of 541 Sqn photographed sea wall gap at 1515 hr. The sea was already flooding in. ‘A’ indicates lighthouse strong point 1 km inland at end of Westkapelle main street; ‘B’ indicates battery of six British guns captured in 1940.

20.

Col Reinhardt, German CO at Flushing, measures the flood waters.

21.

Willy Paugstadt, shot at Middelburg in front of ten-year-old Jan Wigard: Paugstadt, a prisoner, was too tired to keep his hands up.

22.

The grave of Willy Paugstadt.

23.

Mine-flailing ‘Crabs’ coming ashore at Westkapelle; Cpl Himsworth’s tank just leaving LCT737.

24.

Polish Maj Gen Stanislas Maczek talks to war correspondents as Col K. Dworak and Capt T.A. Wysocki pay attention.

25.

Bedraggled infantry trudge yet another mile through yet another devastated village.

26.

A defended farmhouse outside Den Bosch is flamed by a ‘Crocodile’ from Joseph Ellis’s unit.

27.

Infantrymen of 53rd Welsh Division advance through Den Bosch while Resistance man Martin Suiskes watches along a side street; in the British newspaper photo three days later, Suiskes’ face has been blanked out by the censor.

28.

53rd Welsh Division veterans return to Den Bosch in more comfort on the fiftieth anniversary of the liberation.

29.

Tanks of 1st Northamptonshire Yeomanry carry 51st Highland Division men forward in the drive towards the last bridge over the Maas.

30.

Men of the Scottish Black Watch line up the two workhorses of Allied infantry battle, the very accurate Bren m-g and the not always so efficient Sten sub-m-g.

31.

The smoke of battle still obscures a ditched 1NY Sherman, a wrecked Kangaroo and two knocked-out German S-Ps as the Raamsdonk battle ends outside St Lambert’s Church.

32.

Recce Sergeant Kenny Jack, MM (1NY), used an old cartwheel as a traverse turntable for his heavy m-g.

33.

Civilians evacuate a disputed village near Overloon as infantrymen move up.

34.

Sgt George Eardley, VC, MM, after being presented with his Victoria Cross by FM Sir Bernard Montgomery near Overloon.

35.

The good news telegram must at first have caused some worry in Mrs Eardley’s mind, for the yellow forms were also used to convey the news that the next of kin had been killed in action.

36.

Gerhard Stiller and SS panzer comrades rest behind the lines, listening to a portable gramophone first looted from the staff car of a Russian Commissar on the Eastern Front.

37/38.

Taking shelter in the cellars of the Santa Anna psychiatric hospital: patients, orphans, villagers, Resistance workers and escaping Allied servicemen.

39.

An underground weapon repairs workshop of the Dutch Resistance hidden in a picture-framing workshop near Venlo.

40/41.

Evacuees from the Schink family village set out in a snowstorm on their two-day walk to the cattle trucks for an unknown destination, baby Ger Schinck in pram.

42.

The end of the road for wounded German prisoners.

Acknowledgements

In preparing this book I have been fortunate in the number of participants in these same battles who have since produced works of historical or literary importance, particularly Denis Whitaker, George Blackburn, Bill Close, Ian Hammerton and W.R. Bennett. I therefore make no excuse for drawing on their reminiscences as they have kindly encouraged me to do. Sadly Denis died during the period of my research but his widow and co-writer, Shelagh, has continued his encouragement.

A younger writer of a monumental piece of research on Walcheren, Paul Crucq, has also generously opened his files and contacts to me. Professor Terry Copp and his Canadian Military History journal are fundamental sources on Canadian operations.

Several people in Holland and Belgium have gone out of their way to help, including Luc van Gent, Karel Govaerts, Louis Kleijne, Freddy Pille, Dr Ger Schinck and Jan Wigard.

In the UK a number of people pointed me on to, or helped me make, further contacts. Among these were John Brown, Bill James, Don Scott and others mentioned in the notes. Tess Carpenter, who was also ‘there’, was at hand for translations. As always, archivists were ever ready to support, including those at the IWM, Mrs Beech at Keele University Air Photo Library, David Fletcher at Bovington Tank Museum, and the staff of the York and Lancaster, Leicesters, Shropshire and Welsh Museums, as well as the Polish Institute. Now fully on stream is the relatively new Second World War Experience Centre, founded by First World War expert Dr Peter Liddle in Horsforth, whose staff and volunteers were at my service, and to which I am consigning my research papers from previous books.

Among my own 1NY comrades, sadly Bill Moseley died during the writing of this book, but his widow, Jean, was happy to extend his permission to quote. Kenny Jack has also left us, cheerful to the end. Rex Jackson, MM, continues to find unusual books for his old tank mate. A special mention for Reg Spittles: not only is he a continuing fount of reminiscences, he now visits Northampton schools to speak about the realities of war, reflecting the work done by Louis Kleijne and others around the battlefields. My wish would be that more UK schools would open their doors to veterans like Reg at a time when, perhaps more than any moment since 1945, the new generations need to know about the realities of oppression, aggression and liberation.

Finally, but first in the queue of the helpful and encouraging, my wife, Jai, still struggling to find ‘dustable’ areas amid the chaos of my office, but, more often, dispelling the dust of years from my brain. And the staff of Sutton Publishing: Jonathan Falconer, Nick Reynolds and a number of others at Sutton who have always been at hand to help with sensitive and professional advice. Thank you to them all and apologies to any I may have omitted, either above or in the complicated search for personal permission to quote.

Map 1 The ‘Thumb’ – 19/20 September 1944.

Map 2 German retreat to Moerdijk, 1944.

Map 3 South Beveland Isthmus (adapted from W.R. Bennett).

Map 4 Limburg and North Brabant, 1944. The two month-long task of extending the flanks of the Arnhem road up to the barrier of the Maas.

CHAPTER ONE

Beggary and Bravery

The people branded as ‘lunatics’ stood and watched the sane men shooting each other and wondered. Was this some strange form of entertainment put on for their benefit by the establishment? Some perverse ballet? Some horrific cabaret?

The inmates were not to know, nor could they have appreciated, that they were about to be present at an act of bravery as incredible as any that might be found in the annals of the British Army. A new name was to be added to the elite roll of the bravest of the brave: names like that of John Frost at the Arnhem bridge, Leonard Cheshire, Lord Lovat, Wg Cdr Guy Gibson, Lt Col ‘H’ Jones, John William Harper.

John William who?

Like a ready-made fortress le Depôt de Mendicité straddled the Allied line of advance on 29 September 1944. The rank and file of the British Army were notorious for their ability to mispronounce foreign names like ‘Wipers’ (Ypres) in 1914 or ‘Bugger’s Bus’ (Bourguebus) in Normandy 1944. Now Mendicité, with its accented final ‘tay’, was a tough one, and instantly became the ‘Monday City’ for many. Few front-line soldiers in 1944 spoke French and therefore might not know that Mendicité meant ‘Beggary’: Depôt de Mendicité – the ‘Beggary Deposit’.

Both John William Harper, ‘Jack’ to family and friends, and John R. Dean, ‘Dixie’ to his mates, were worried about the Monday City. It was just a blob on the map between Rijkevorsel (pronounced ‘rake-for-sell’) and Merxplas in north Belgium. They had been told that it was a lunatic asylum and that the loonies were still inside. So there would be no devastating air raid or huge artillery barrage to mash the buildings into ruins before the infantry attack. Nothing larger than hand-thrown grenades or small mortar bombs, delivered with pin-point accuracy by the company mortar sections, would be used.

The attackers, from the Hallamshires and Leicestershires, had at first envisaged a vast, solid, single building like a British asylum. When Harper’s company were told that they had to find a back way in, they anticipated charging straight up to the edifice and smashing through doors and windows while under direct fire from defenders who would be using patients as protection. In fact the Depôt de Mendicité was a totally different proposition. It was more of the style of a huge military camp. The confusion was not confined to front line troops, for 1 Corps HQ itself reported the Hallams and Leicesters ‘attacking a factory’ that day.

The original name of the institution, founded in 1822, would have confounded even the most capable linguists in the attacking 49th ‘Polar Bear’ Division: Maatschappij van Weldadigheid voor de Zuidelijke Nederlanden.

King Willem I of the Netherlands (Belgium was then part of the Netherlands) had instituted a colony for tramps. In 1870 the hospitality was extended to include paupers, beggars and drunkards, and gained its 1940s name. Gradually parts of the compound were turned over for use as a civil prison.1

It was the occupying German authorities of the First World War who set up a lunatic asylum there, providing secure accommodation for mentally ill people from Belgium and northern France, many of whom could, at that time, be treated only by restraint methods. Just before the Second World War, Jewish refugees were also offered shelter. Then with the 1940 German occupation Belgian and Dutch hostages were interned in the prison section.

Some idea of the size of the establishment may be gained from the fact that up to 6,000 persons could be accommodated there, of whom at the time of the battle 1,740 were prisoners. Only a relatively small percentage of the 1940s residents were classed as lunatics, the majority being vagabonds. But it is reasonable to estimate that several hundred occupants were mentally ill, and the prison also housed many who were criminally insane. This vast establishment, originally set up as 125 small farms for indigent families, lay as a physical obstacle across the Allied route and posed a unique humanitarian problem for the commanders planning their attack.

After the collapse of the German armies in Normandy, the Allies had rushed across France and most of Belgium in a drive towards the heartland of Germany. But in the north of Belgium the German resistance began to stiffen behind the many wide waterways and deep ditches of the low lands. Already men of the 49th ‘Polar Bear’ Division had been forced to fight bitter skirmishes around Rijkevorsel.2 Accompanying tanks of the Polish Armoured Division were held up by a bridge across a wide moat. The moat was part of the Mendicité complex, a twenty-foot-wide water obstacle designed to prevent inmates from exiting but equally effective in preventing invaders from entering.

So both Cpl Jack Harper and Sgt Dixie Dean had good cause to be worried. Jack Harper’s platoon of the Hallamshires was to lead the way across 300 yards of open ground without shelter against undamaged, well-prepared defences. Dixie Dean with the 1st Leicesters was responsible for getting the vital mortars supplied for their daunting task as substitutes for Lancaster bombers and siege guns. Each company had two of the light 3-inch mortars. Each mortar section was commanded by a sergeant with a no. 18 radio set in touch with the company (coy) commander, so that speed and accuracy could be assured as the infantry advanced.

Dixie Dean, later RSM (Regimental Sergeant Major), remembers the battle vividly:

At dawn on Friday 29th September, the Bn attacked the Depôt de Mendicité which was a lunatic asylum and this was without doubt the most deadly action we had fought to date [they had fought through Normandy!]. The plan for this attack was given out by the Adjutant, Captain North. ‘A’ Coy to go south of the main road, ‘B’ Coy north, ‘C’ pass through ‘B’, then ‘B’ in reserve. . . . ‘A’ Coy moving through the woods were the first to run into the enemy and Lt Guy was killed. . . . They lost direction in the confusion and were pinned down for hours by the enemy.3

To the left of the Leicesters’ position, men of C, the lead coy of the Hallamshires, looked out from the thick woods and studied their task. Capt Mike Lonsdale-Cooper with Lt Judge and Cpl Harper had no illusions about that pleasant green level sward stretching from the trees to a far embankment. Yorkshire ‘Tykes’, from the champion cricket county of the 1930s, they would have seen the area as an ideal place for a cricket match with long boundaries each end. Now their bowlers would have to demonstrate their skills at lobbing hand grenades. The bomb, which fitted in the palm of the hand, was normally lobbed rather than thrown direct, firstly in order to drop vertically beyond obstacles and secondly to allow three seconds for the fuse to activate, so that the enemy had no time to pick up the grenade and throw it back.

Dug deep into the far embankment and as yet invisible, the enemy had available, in addition to their own long-handled grenades, the awesome Spandau machine-gun (m-g). The defenders of the asylum had been reinforced by a fresh battalion and were lined up in considerable numbers around the perimeter. Facing Lonsdale-Cooper’s coy may have been four or more of the rapid-firing m-gs, each of which could spit out over a thousand rounds a minute, or nearly twenty bullets a second, and every bullet potentially fatal. The rapid fire meant that the m-gs were not very accurate in comparison to a sniper’s accuracy. Yet they produced a whirling cone of bullets, widening as they sped spinning from the muzzles, and forming a dense horizontal hail of death over a wide area of ground.

It might appear hopeless for men to attempt a 300-yard walk, or weaving trot, in the face of such fire, remembering that the weight of weapons and equipment made it difficult for even the fittest infantryman to sprint such a distance. But Lonsdale-Cooper and Judge knew there were also a few factors in their favour. As soon as the m-gs started to fire, their positions would be revealed and they would be prime targets for the Hallams’ mortar bombs, which could be on target with less than a minute’s notice. In addition the elite German units were congregated around Arnhem so that those defending the Depôt de Mendicité would be less skilled and resolute than the superhuman, infallible German soldiers of more recent Allied myths.

Rapid though it was, the Spandau could not fire incessantly without pauses to reload or to make changes of target, which could affect accuracy. Because of the great expenditure of ammunition those m-gs had to fire relatively short bursts. German hand grenades, too, were known to be fallible. Normal German Army units, as distinct from the SS, were being reinforced with poor quality ‘dug out’ men, some very old or very young for front-line duty. Ordinary enemy soldiers would be as fearful and ready to hide from hostile fire as were the attackers themselves.

Having said that, there was a real possibility that the entire Hallamshire coy could be wiped out or forced to go to ground, seeking shelter in the sparse contours of the rough field. There was no advantage in argument or delay. Judge and Harper and their comrades set off across that horribly open space the size of a test match cricket field. Immediately they were greeted by crashing, blazing torrents of fire, heralding high velocity bullets and jagged shards of iron as well as solid clods and stones wrenched from the ground by explosions. It was like walking through a cloud of smoke in which every particle was a shrieking, tearing sliver of sharp death.

As the wary, sweating infantrymen chose their own way forward, some hastening to gain the embankment, others diving, leaping up, swerving in fruitless attempts to become invisible, men began to fall. Roy Simon had been wounded in Normandy in June, had spent time in British hospitals, and now was back with his comrades for his first battle in Belgium. He was shot almost immediately. Another young recruit, nervously waiting to hear his first shots fired in anger, probably never heard the bullet that killed him. Lt Judge was hit in the neck and fell, incapable of thought or action. Harper walked on.

In his brief return to war Roy Simon had been a hero, modest though he was about it:

We were in a ditch on the edge of this wood and what happened next was Errol Flynn stuff. We were lined up and they were shelling us and Lonsdale-Cooper was at the side of me and he said, ‘Right. Get ready’, and he were looking at his watch. Then all of a sudden he blows his whistle and I gets half out of the ditch and nowt happens.

Nobody moved! And he says to me, ‘Come on, Simon,’ he says, ‘You’re one of the old lads, show them how it’s done.’ So I gets up and I shouts, ‘Come on the Hallams, let’s go’ and I sets off running. . . . We got half way across and I was running like the clappers with nothing to fire at, and everything seemed to be coming at us.4

As men fell, some mates ran faster while others took more urgent evasive action. It mattered not which action the individual took. Death and wounding ranged everywhere, horizontally, vertically, diagonally. And as the advance shortened the distance remaining, it brought the attackers within range of the defenders’ stick grenades. Then the infamous Nebelwerfers, groups of six mortar bombs with their ‘Moaning Minnie’ sirens, found the range and added to the inferno. In the lead, Harper, briefly noticing that Judge was down and that he was now in charge of the point attackers, walked on.

The ‘running’, as Simon described it, of a fully accoutred infantryman tends eventually to become more of a shambling, stumbling progress across uneven ground. The more active leaders could not move too far in advance of their less agile supporters. Five minutes could have elapsed during the erratic movement as the advancing ranks staggered, thinned, disintegrated, disappeared.

On the defenders’ side there may have been some damping down of fire. Weapons became overheated. Ammunition needed to be replenished. Wounds had to be dressed. Dead bodies dragged out of the way. Pits, demolished by enemy fire, cleared of debris or new refuge found.

Above all the defender would be impressed by the success of his own fire as the vast majority of the attacking force sought refuge in depressions in the earth or lay about as dead or badly wounded bodies in full view. The vigorous attacking force, a clear, tempting target, had faded into a vague chimera with one or two indistinct figures still moving in the landscape. Just one slight man wearing a corporal’s stripes still trudged on, near at hand and easy for someone else to shoot somewhere else along the unbroken line of the embankment defences.

There are moments of minor climax in battle when the defender thinks ‘We’ve won that round!’ And relaxes for a moment. Pauses before the next round. Takes a deep breath. Lights a fag. Has a puff. Passes it to a mate. Checks the gun. Urinates.

And then the vague figure with the corporal’s stripes becomes a yelling monster leaping at the gun pits, throwing bomb after bomb which explode in all directions, spreading lethal splinters at cowering foes. Lobbing more bombs over the embankment where skulking defenders are bewildered by the sudden assault. Leaping up high and alone on to the embankment where he has no right to be, and which is supposed to be the domain of the defenders, and where he now dominates the slit trenches that had seemed so safe.

In battle there can be a kind of hysteria which inspires a wave of attackers to forget the odds and accomplish miracles. There is a similar hysteria which affects surprised defenders, causing sometimes instant surrender, sometimes confused flight, sometimes berserk response. The ordinary German soldiers, confronted by this apparition in their midst, wilted and suffered themselves to be overawed and scattered, dead, wounded, fleeing or surrendering. Harper, undaunted, climbed back over the earthen bulwark, shepherding four prisoners and still firing at those who were retreating.

With Lt Judge disabled, the coy commander had gathered men together in the shelter of the ‘home’ side of the embankment. Their orders were clear. Find a back way into the depot and exploit. Harper offered to cross the obstacle again to find out whether the moat beyond could be waded. As he descended at the far side on to the banks of the moat, the entire area was still being deluged by fire from several directions. Carefully he crouched down by the moat, or may even have stepped down into it, to test its depth. Nobody else was there to see, in any case. Clearly it was too deep to ford. He returned to Lonsdale-Cooper with his report. The major ordered him to get the survivors of his platoon on to the banks of the moat.

Harper, in the lead, crossing the embankment for the third time, found the German gun pits on that side still empty. Ordering covering fire at the buildings beyond the water, he encouraged his men over the obstruction and down into the pits, only one man being hit in the process. He then went walking along the bank, alone, totally exposed, looking for a possible crossing place of the twenty-foot-wide water obstacle.

On that side of the embankment the close-range crossfire from within the depot was, if anything, worse than it had been in the open field. There were more Spandaus located beyond hand-grenade range in or between the buildings. By some miracle Harper managed to move a considerable distance along the bank, still looking for a ford.

His quest took him beyond the battalion’s boundary where he found an outpost of the Leicesters. They had located a ford and were able to point it out to him. Once more the corporal made his way back through the inescapable turbulence of air displaced by myriad hurtling projectiles and almost visibly ablaze with tracer fire and explosions. Enemy gunners, angry and baffled, continued to aim at the lone figure, and to miss, possibly due to the undisciplined frenzy of firing. Up to that point, because of the exigencies of battle and the finality of the outcome, there is no clear indication as to whether Harper, at some time or in some way, might have been wounded. It would have been typical of him to carry on anyway.

Capt (later Maj) Mike Lonsdale-Cooper had also risked his life, climbing over the embankment and venturing out on to the banks of the dyke. Jack Harper, mission accomplished, was able to direct the major to the vital ford. The back door to the ‘Monday City’ was open. At that precise moment, a chance bullet, or one fired with more precision by a more careful sniper, found him at last, and he fell grievously wounded. Mike Lonsdale-Cooper quickly realized that nothing could be done. There on the bank of the moat John William Harper, a reluctant soldier, had died.5

Other soldiers of the Sheffield Battalion, the Hallamshires, fought and suffered as the unit probed into the asylum. Arnold Whiteley was accompanying Maj Cooper across the moat:

We made our crossing and as we ran across you could hear the bullets whizzing. We were well spaced out and it were only Maj Cooper who got hit. Of course, when we got under cover of banking on the other side, I said, ‘Thank God nobody got hit’, and he said, ‘You speak for your bloody self!’ He was shot straight through his left arm. Another six inches in and he would have been finished.

Roy Simon in his brief cameo battle found that shots were hitting his mates from an angle high up, perhaps from a roof in the complex:

I looked around and our lads were going down and stretchers were being called for. . . . Where I was laid down I raised my rifle to my shoulder. I was just going to pull trigger when all of a sudden I heard this terrific bang at the side of my ear. I stood straight up and spun round and fell back, but this L/Cpl caught me. Then I felt this warmth down me back and I said to this Lance Jack, ‘What’s me back like?’ He said there was blood coming out and the same bullet had passed through me and hit him in the wrist.

One of the young lads came running over with both hands up in the air and he had been shot through both wrists while taking aim. Then Gerry started mortaring us. Shells were falling in a pattern and bodies were going up all round.

Meanwhile Arnold Whiteley with others had arrived inside the barriers to the asylum and observed just how close the fighting was:

The lads who were in close proximity were eye-ball to eye-ball over this banking and they must have seen each other and killed simultaneously. There was only a few yards between our dead and theirs. We got into the compound and they starting giving themselves up and I was with Maj Cooper when the lads started to tell him about Cpl Harper and his deeds.

After his wounding Roy Simon had either fainted or dozed off, sitting with his back against the side of a trench. Suddenly he came to his senses to see with horror that several German soldiers were approaching him. Were they going to shoot him? Or take him prisoner? What a fate, to spend the rest of the war in a prisoner-of-war camp. He could do nothing about it:

They were coming closer to me. They looked at two or three of our lads and then came to me. I tried to raise my rifle. Then somebody said it was all right and that they’d do me no harm as they were stretcher bearers. One of them looked at me and he were nearly old enough to be me Granddad.

It gradually sank into Roy’s befuddled mind that the German stretcher-bearers were themselves prisoners and that the battle was over and won. So the Germans attended to him:

They picked me up and, using my rifle as a chair, carried me along this earthen bank and then turned over a little bridge. We went into this kind of a barn and they sat me down. A German came over and treated my wound with my own field dressing and covered it with some of theirs. He took his own coat off and put it round me to keep me warm.

Roy also saw Mike Lonsdale-Cooper come in with his arm in a sling. But the German medic’s kindness almost caused Roy problems. On his way back down the line he was thought to be a German prisoner of war because he was wearing the German greatcoat. His Yorkshire accent soon dispelled that impression. Nearly sixty years later Roy was taken back to the battle site by regimental historian Don Scott. He was amazed to find the little barn still there. He was able to sit again on the same seat built into the wall where he sat while his wound was dressed.

To the right of the Hallams’ attack, the Leicesters were going in through the front door, as it were. Their experience was very similar. Their regimental aid post, established in a nearby house, was soon very busy. Sgt Dixie Dean saw several of his friends being rushed into the post, ‘Major Blackstock and Sgt Goodlad of “A” and Sgts Goodacre and Payne, and Ptes Lewitt and Bradshaw of “C” among others’.6

References to a ‘back door’ and ‘front door’ are figurative and could be misleading, as this was not a single simple building. A more complete description of what the Leicesters saw in front of them would be informative as they would have had a clear view from the bridge, which formed the main entrance across the moat. The waterway itself, with its high embankment, was 7 km long and between 10 and 12 metres wide throughout its length. It enclosed a domain of 600 hectares (nearly 1,500 acres). There were 27 km of streets and lanes running through the compound and dividing up the various sections of the complex.7

The ‘dormitories’ for the paupers were solid four-storey buildings, a wide avenue of them leading up to a large chapel. The prison buildings surrounded an inner square of 4 hectares. There was a Great Farm and a Small Farm. The population required its own hospital, workshops, stores, offices and so on. In addition to other areas providing casual work for the unskilled ‘vagabonds’, there was also a large brickworks, its tall stacks of bricks forming yet more narrow alleys to be explored.

As he supervised the ammunition for the mortars of the various companies now advancing into this unfamiliar maze, Dixie Dean had a good general view of the battalion’s progress. He saw B Coy wading across the moat at the place which they had pointed out to Jack Harper. He observed C Coy passing through B in an enthusiastic charge, then being caught in ruthless m-g crossfire until they were counter-attacked and temporarily surrounded by a fresh German battalion, from 719th Infantry Division, whose presence was unknown to the British commanders.

In any other battle the word would have gone out for rocket Typhoons or medium artillery to strafe the defenders. But with the harmless civilians, many of them seriously mentally ill, still in the complex it could only be urgent calls to Dixie Dean’s ‘pop-gun’ mortars to assist the infantrymen. One Leicester attacker recorded that, at this point, ‘The Germans let out the inmates who were just standing around looking at us as if we were the mad ones. They were being killed left, right and centre but there was nothing we could do to save them.’

The next hazard to which the mortars were directed was the area of brickworks within the prison area. Maj Denaro led the attack into this section which was a maze of alleyways formed out of the stacks of bricks.

To the Leicesters this was unknown ground but the defenders knew its layout and used the brick stacks for shelter. Denaro and his men had to rush each alleyway, one by one, losing men at every turning. Here again, a normal artillery bombardment would have flattened the loose brick stacks and saved many casualties among the soldiers, but would also have wrought massive slaughter of incapable patients, paupers and civil prisoners.

Dixie Dean’s recollections of the fight are tragic, with the constant refrain of good comrades being cut down in a ruthless fight where the man at the sharp end paid the price of laudable humanitarian considerations:

The enemy was in an ideal position in a kind of brickworks, with its alleyways and mounds affording good cover. Maj Denaro had gone forward and was killed here. Cpls Hodges and Beck and L/Cpls Smith, Kiddier and Mitchell were all killed here. Making good use of the dykes and ditches the enemy continued to play havoc with ‘C’ coy and Sgt Skelton, L/Cpl Clements and Ptes Palmer, Elliott, Preston and Hart were all killed. As the enemy withdrew the occupants of the asylum were released, thus providing cover for the retreating troops.

What distressed many of the Leicesters after the battle, where they had witnessed Denaro’s inspiring leadership and sad death, was that, because he died, he was denied the Distinguished Service Order award which his men thought should have been his. Under the awards system an officer killed in action could only receive the rare VC or a Mention In Despatches, but not the more appropriate DSO or MC. The men could not understand why this should be so. Surely bravery to the death should be quite as good an eligibility as bravery with survival?

This strange quirk of the awards system did not diminish the admiration of the men for those who did receive awards. One who received the Military Cross, all the more significant because it was an immediate award, was Lt V.F.W. Bidgood. His platoon had been in a similar advance to that of Lt Judge and Cpl Harper. Their target was the small bridge over the moat near the main entrance.

Like Judge’s platoon, they had open ground to cross from their sheltering wood, about 250 yards. Again the advance had to be made against defences which had escaped the ravages of air or heavy artillery bombardment. Again the Spandaus ripped out their deadly challenge with a noise faster than any side drummer could play. Again men fell as they braved the open spaces. By the fortune which favours some and not others, a number of Bidgood’s platoon survived and, joined by Sgt Poole’s platoon, they subdued the defenders of the bridge, ran across it and established a small ‘bridgehead’ within the compound.

Men of all ranks exhibited similar valour. At the bottom of the military hierarchy and without a rifle, Pte C.H. Woods won the Military Medal. Woods was a stretcher-bearer and went forward with the lead platoons. Once the bridge had been secured, the infantrymen found or dug cover on either side of it. The enemy poured m-g and mortar on the bridge to try to prevent Leicester reinforcements from moving up. Woods, forward of the bridge and finding several wounded men in need of urgent treatment, crossed the bridge time and time again assisted by volunteer bearers. A number of lives were saved by the prompt surgical treatment enabled by the extremely high-risk rescue work of Woods.

Sgt Dean noted that the Leicesters’ C Coy had been reduced to forty-three men surviving out of nearly a hundred. A Coy ‘had taken a pretty good hammering but the Bn had good reason to be proud of its first really BIG show’ of the autumn campaign. Dixie and his weary mortar men were delighted next day on advancing again to hear ‘our heavy guns keeping up a seemingly never-ending barrage and accompanied by heavy bombers and Typhoons’. They were also thinking ‘If only . . . !’

The taste of victory was not as sweet as might have been the case if it had been a real fort or a factory which had been cleared of the enemy. Soldiers expected to find other soldiers dead and dying on a battlefield. They found it more difficult to deal with the sight of numbers of helpless civilians similarly slaughtered. Outside the buildings lay those civilians who had been caught in the crossfire – paupers, prisoners, ‘lunatics’ and, perhaps most sadly, detained Belgian and Dutch heroes and hostages who had been betrayed by fate at the moment of release. And the atmosphere within some of the buildings was depressing, even frightening.

Walter Shea was with the 62nd Anti-Tank Regt, Royal Artillery. His unit was moving up in close support for the infantry against possible counter-attack. As they moved into the buildings Shea was not feeling particularly bellicose. He recorded years later:

They’d got there a big civil prison. What they done they let them out . . . they’d opened the cages and these were criminally insane people. The German troops were falling back. And the prison guards they weren’t anywhere to be seen. There were the two of us. We had a pistol and a Sten gun, but walking in there, and several of these insane people wandering around loose, even with our guns we were feeling quite a bit wary of them. We weren’t happy anyway because we lost our C.O. killed there – a wonderful guy.8

The British Army does not ‘send up medals with the rations’, and the number of awards for gallantry that day illustrates the fierceness of the fighting. Apart from Harper, who won the VC, and Denaro, who died denied a medal, the DSO went to Capt P. Upcher; the MC to Lt Bidgood and Lt F.A. Gaunt, who was with Denaro in the brickworks; and Military Medals to Sgts W. Irwin and T. Johnson, L/Cpl W.A. Saunders, and Ptes C.H. Woods and H.T. Gill, the latter also a stretcher-bearer. Their efforts, and those of their comrades, had cleared the main road for the waiting Polish armoured division to dash on its way towards Tilburg. The dead were buried eventually in Leopoldsburg war cemetery.

Some of the local people had suffered badly during the battle, even without counting the damage to property. Sixty-three-year-old Frans Mertens was serving a sentence in the prison wing. For him, liberation was good news and bad news. Suddenly he was afforded the chance of an unexpected early release. Then equally suddenly he received an undeserved death sentence. He was killed by a rifle bullet, perhaps fired by the Germans, perhaps by the British. Nobody could tell in the confusion.

Prison warden August Meeusen, aged fifty-nine and looking forward to retirement from the service, was killed, as were a further nine detainees. Seventeen of the inmates were badly wounded. The confusion looked to be a good thing for some German soldiers who hastily doffed more visible elements of weaponry and uniform and mixed with the crowd of inmates, hoping thus to escape prisoner-of-war captivity.

The official citation for Cpl Harper’s Victoria Cross clearly details the enormity of the mission undertaken by Harper and his colleagues:

In Northwest Europe, on September 29th, 1944, the Hallamshire Battalion of the York and Lancaster Regiment attacked the Depôt de Mendicité, a natural defensive position surrounded by an earthen wall, and then a dyke strongly held by the enemy.

Corporal Harper was commanding the leading section in the assault. The enemy were well dug in and had a perfect field of fire across 300 yards of perfectly flat and exposed country. With superb disregard for the hail of mortar bombs and small arms fire which the enemy brought to bear upon this open ground, Corporal Harper led his section straight up to the wall [earthen embankment] and killed or captured the enemy holding the near side. During this operation the platoon commander was seriously wounded and Corporal Harper took over control of the platoon.

The citation then describes Harper’s three sallies over the ‘wall’ and his lone walk to find a crossing place over or through the moat. It ends: ‘the success of the Battalion in driving the enemy from the wall and back across the dyke must be largely ascribed to the superb self sacrifice and inspiring gallantry of Corporal Harper. His magnificent courage, fearlessness, and devotion to duty throughout the battle set a splendid example to his men and had a decisive effect on the course of the operations.’

The citation was written by a staff officer, but those who ‘were there’ might demur at the use of the word ‘fearlessness’. Certainly Harper was courageous and devoted to duty and sacrificial, but whether he was without fear is a moot question. The vast majority of front-line soldiers knew fear and many had to fight it as vigorously as they fought the physical enemy.

What is known about Harper’s personality would suggest that, like other quiet men, he had won a prolonged battle against fear without totally eliminating it.

Who, then, was this John William Harper? Whence came he? And what sort of man was he?

Mike Lonsdale-Cooper, by then a major, wrote to Harper’s wife while recovering from his own wound. He said, after briefly describing the battle, and stating that Harper’s death came from a sniper’s bullet and that he died ‘instantly’:

He was a very brave man and the best type of N.C.O. and it was an honour to have him with me in battle and out. He was always quietly efficient, always cheerful, and somehow gave everybody a feeling of confidence . . . we are mourning the loss of a brave soldier and a very fine man.

Surprisingly, although a memorial plaque was placed in nearby Doncaster, Harper’s own village of Hatfield Woodhouse in Yorkshire had no memorial to him until fifty-eight years after the battle. Then ex-mayor and present Rotarian treasurer, John Brown, proposed a public appeal for remembrance of the VC in that tiny country hamlet where he was born. In 2002, outside the chapel of the churchyard at Hatfield Woodhouse, an impressive black granite stone was unveiled to recall Harper’s bravery.9