TheBlottingPaper
BY
ChandanSukumarSengupta
ISBN9789355591791©ChandanSukumarSengupta2021PublishedinIndia2021byPencilAbrandofOnePointSixTechnologiesPvt.Ltd.123,BuildingJ2,ShramSevaPremises,WadalaTruckTerminal,Wadala(E)Mumbai400037,Maharashtra,INDIAEconnect@thepencilapp.comWwww.thepencilapp.comAllrightsreservedworldwideNopartofthispublicationmaybereproduced,storedinorintroducedintoaretrievalsystem,ortransmitted,inanyform,orbyanymeans(electronic,mechanical,photocopying,recordingorotherwise),withoutthepriorwrittenpermissionofthePublisher.Anypersonwhocommitsanunauthorizedactinrelationtothispublicationcanbeliabletocriminalprosecutionandcivilclaimsfordamages.
DISCLAIMER:TheopinionsexpressedinthisbookarethoseoftheauthorsanddonotpurporttoreflecttheviewsofthePublisher.
Authorbiography
AuthorisworkinginthefieldofScienceandTechnologysince1995.Morethan150differenttitleswerepublishedthroughdifferentNationalaswellasInternationalPPublishinghouses.
Contents
PowerPolitics
TheOtherSideofCoin
WhatWeLearn!
AddressingAspirations
CareManagement
HumanAspirations
EverlastingResolutions
IntellectualRectification
StateofMind
ASpecialMoment
Preface
ThehistoryofAfghanistandatesbacktotheepicsandbeforethesocialisationofpeopleneartheKandaharValley.Itisalandlockedcountry.Ithad31.4millionresidentsduring2020.Thelandwasinvadedperiodically bymanyinvadorslikeAlexander,Aryans,Mughals,Turks,British,RussiansandAmericansduringlast20years.Foralongertimeduring19thCenturyitworkedasabufferstatebetweenGreatEmpiresofBritishandRussians.
Mujahideenrebelsweresmasheddownduring1980sbyRussiansandthestategotitsidentityintheformofaSocialistRepublic.OnceagainalmostallpartsofthecountrywerecapturedbyIslamicfundamentalistsbytheendof1996.Theycameinpowerandruleadasatotalitarianregimefornearaboutfiveyears.AnothertwistinthehistoryofAfghanistancameintheformofinvationofUSledNATOforcesforsmashingdownIslamicextremists.Talibanwereremovedfromthepowerduring2001butostofthepartsofthecountryremainedintheiroperationaldominance.
CoincidingwiththereturnofUSforcesTalibantookadvantageandimpliedaholdupontheNationalSecuritysystem.Theyevencompelledthepresidentofthatcountrytoleavethecapital.
Thesedaysthecountryisexperiencinghighlevelofcorruption,malpracticesandlawlessness.Peoplesufferalotduetolackofqualityfoodandproperschooling.Womenandchildrenofthesocietyaremorevulnerable.Theirchanceofaccesstolawandjudiciaryisfeeble.OnceinoldentimestheplacewasruledefficientlybyHindurulers.During11thCenturyMahmudofGhajnidefeatedHindurulersandIslamisedmostofthepartsofAfghanistan.
Sinceoldentimestheareahadexperienceddifferentupsanddownsandneverworkedoutanyunityamongthem.Bytheendof1747AfghanistanstartedorganisingitselfundertheleadershipofAhmadShahDurrani.AfterthedeathofDurranithepartialwaknessinorganisingsecurityforceswastakenupbySikhsandBritish.Theyear1919cameinthehistoryofAfghanistanwhichbroughtcompletefreedomforthepeople.Thenationsoonindulgedinacivilwar(1928-29)bringingutterunrestfortheentireterritory.[1] Theyear1989to1992wastheaotherteureofcivilwarfollowedbyRussianinterventiontomakeitasocialistrepublic.USledNATOforcesenteredthescenarioduring2001tomakeitademocraticrepublic.
Atpresentsomeotherstatesareworkingoutacomprehensiveplantoenterthenationalpolitics.TheyarealsoinamoodtoexploreresourcesofthecountryforgrabbingitandforutilisingitbypartformakingthelifeofAfghanpeopleprosperous.
ChandanSengupta
Author
[1]Muḥammad,Fayz̤;McChesney,R.D.(1999).Kabulundersiege:FayzMuhammad'saccountofthe1929Uprising.MarkusWienerPublishers.pp.39,40.ISBN9781558761544.Archivedfromtheoriginalon4April2019.Retrieved15June2019.
Introduction
Afghanistanisbecomingawidelydiscussedissueduringthebeginningofthe21stcenturybecauseoftheinvolvementofOsamaBinLadeninorganizingaplannedattackinUSAandtheentryofUSledNATOintheAfghanarenaforsmashingextremistsdowntheframe.Itwassince2001onwardsthattheentireworldhaswitnessedtheeffortsofNATOforsocializingvarousrebelsofAfghanbase.WemovebacktolookuponthehistoricalrecordsafterwhichthegloryofAfghanpeoplewentontrailing.
IndiaisdifferentlyrelatedtothepeopleofAfghanistaninvariousways.OnceAfghanrulerSherShahinvadedIndiamainlandfordefeatingMughalsanddulyestablishedhisempireinDelhi.Hiscapabilitiesofadministrationandlandreformssystemwereproperlywelcomedbyhistorians.NotonlyhadthecaseofSherShah,otherrulersofAfghanoriginalsoinvadedtheIndiamainlandandaspiredforwinningtheconfidenceoflocalpeople.HistorychangeditscoursewhilekeepingpacewithmodernizationandAfghanslosttheirwayinthemiddleatthebeginningof20thcentury.Theyevenfailedtoexploretheplentyofresourcestheyhadintheirmines.Modernization,Industrialisation,mechanizationofservicessectorandrightsofgirlsandwomenweresomeofthefieldsremainedneglectedevenaftertheWorldWarII.
CountriesmaintainingcrossculturalaswellastraderelationswithAfghanistanwantedtoexploredifferentpossibilitiesofexploringresourcesforthepurposeofacceleratingthepaceofdevelopment.Theonlyobstaclethathamperedtheiradvancementwasthecontinuationofconflictsamongstthedifferentsettlementsofthecountry.
Afghanistanhasbeenthehometovariouspeople.ItwasalsoaseatofseriesofmilitaryoperationsincludingthosemadebyAlexander,Aryans,Mughals,Arabs,British,RussiansandevenbyUSandNATOforces.Itremainedunconquerableandgotanickname“thegraveyardofempires.”[1]ThenameGandhara,asdepictedintheepicTheMahabharata,wastheplaceincludingpartsofSindh,PunjabandmodernAfghanistan.IthadmilitaryandpoliticalassociationswithAryansandgotanickname“theHinduShahi[2].” Ultimatelythetimecameduringwhichthefirstnon-militaryprimeministertookthechargeofAfghanistan.[3]
Theseriesofbattlesandotheroppressiveinvasionswentonpitchinginregularlyinthelandofprosperity.Theconflictwentonmushroomingsidebysidebecauseofinfiltrationofseveralintendersoftheopportunists.[4]ThecostofSovietinvasionwasmarkedintheformofhundredsandthousandsofkillingsanddisplacementsofsixmillionpeoplefromtheirhomes.[5]ThesituationagintosseddifferentlywhenUSArmyandalliedNATOtroopsfinalizedtoquitthelandbeforeSeptember2021.Afghanistanconflicthasraisedseveralquestionsandalsocompelledustothinkaboutthedefiniteroleoftheworldcommunitytowardsnullifyingtheconflictwithaninstantaneouseffortandcourage.Italsomotivatedusdifferentlytothinkaboutthestandofleadingnationstowardsbringingnormalcyinthestate.
Accordingtoanotherestimatenearly400,000Afghansdiedduring1990-2001tenureundervariousconflictingcircumstances.[6]After2001scenario,AfghanistanwasinvadedagaintobringTalibandownfromthepower.ThistimetheleaderintheframeofdiscussionwasUSA.TheirroleinAfghanistanwasconsideredasaback-footracewith certaininflictionsofmechanizingthewarfareofthecountry.Theyhavedecidedtoquittherunwaysonorbefore31stAugust2021atanycost.ItwasatthecostofpeopleandcurrencyofAfghanistan.Herealsoquestionarises:IsthereanythinginparticularthatforcedUSAtoquit?WhattheroleexactlyplayedbyChina,RussiaorTurkiinthisregard?Whatformatofpowerpoliticsforcedtheleadingnationstoquitthefireplace?HundredsandthousandsofthesetypesofquestionscanberaisedwithanobjectiveoftracingouttherootcauseoftheproblemwhichhasmountedontheelectronicmediainthenameofAfghanistanandTaliban.
ItisnotforthefirsttimethatAmericansworkedoutaresolutiontoquitthelandofconflictingsituation,itisalsonotforthefirsttimethatpeopleofAfghanistanleftinthemiddleatthemercyofGod.Theyhadtofighttheirownpeoplewhomaintainoptimumfaithuponarmsandwarfare.Theypeoplealsomaintainanurgetoaspireforanascenttocopeupwiththerapiddevelopmentthattheworldoutsideismovingthrough.Peopleofthatcountryalsointendtocomeupwithapeoplefriendlygovernancewhichcanaccommodateaspirationsofcommuneinabroaderspectrum. Evenaftera20longyearsofrunupthegoalwasyettobesetproperly.ItisknowntousnowthatalltherationbagsofAfghanipeoplearefilledupwithfirecrackersandguns.Theyhadonlyonetasktobeaccomplished:fightagainsteachotherandgoonpracticingarmedexercises.
ArethepeopleofAfghanistanreallyunderthetremendousthreatbecauseofthemushroomingofarmedexercisesofrebelsfromdifferentout-pocketsofthecountry?AretheyreallyunderaquestionmarkintermsoftheirchancesofbeingsmashedbytherebelsandviolenttroopsofTaliban?Willitgivebirthtopeopletopeopleconflictatlast?
WewilltrytofindouttheissuesandconcernsrelatedtothearmedexercisesthatgotitsprominenceafterthemonthofAugust2021.Itwasreallyafactwhichdrewtheattentionoftheworldcommunityandpeopleindulgedincalculationsbyallmeanstofindouttherealreasonbehindtheutterfailureofanationalarmyinsafeguardingpeopleofacountry.Presidentofacountryquitsleavingbehindalltheotherpeopleofacountry.Againthatpersoncomesbackandseeksforgivenessforhisconduct.Itisthefactwhichraisesquestionsonthecredibilityandloyaltyofanorganizedarmytowardscateringservicestothecitizenofacountry.Entirestructureofanationalsecurityissuecameunderquestionmark.
[1]TheGraveyardofEmpiresisasobriquetassociatedwithAfghanistan.ThesobriquetoriginatesfromthehistoricaltendencythatforeignpowersoftenfailintheirinvasionsofAfghanistan.Itisunclearwhocoinedthephrase,anditshistoricalaccuracyhasbeendisputed.
[2]Wink,André(2002).Al-Hind,theMakingoftheIndo-IslamicWorld:EarlyMedievalIndiaandtheExpansionofIslam7Th-11thCenturies.BRILL.p.125.ISBN0-391-04173-8.Archivedfromtheoriginalon1December2019.Retrieved11December2019.
[3]Eur(2002).TheFarEastandAustralasia2003.PsychologyPress.p.62.ISBN978-1-85743-133-9.
[4]"Afghanistan:20yearsofbloodshed".BBC.26April1998.Archivedfromtheoriginalon17February2019.Retrieved4July2019.
[5]"RefugeeAdmissionsProgramforNearEastandSouthAsia".BureauofPopulation,Refugees,andMigration.Archivedfromtheoriginalon22January2017.Retrieved29December2013.
[6]"LifeunderTalibancutstwoways".CSM.20September2001Archived30December2013attheWaybackMachine
PowerPolitics
PolarisedPower
Countriesaroundtheworldstartedmaintainingtheirdifferenceofopinionregardingthewayrebelsmountedtosmashthenationalsecuritysystemandforcedasegmentofthecommunitytoquitinstantly.IslamicstatesmaintaineddifferenceofopinionregardingtheactsofTalibanandstarteddesignatingitasanactoffreedomfromtheforeigninvasion.CountrieslikeChinaandTurksstartedexploring anaccommodationtogetindulgeinthereconstructionworksaftertheexitofAmerica.TheyexpressedtheireagernesstomodifythewavesofothercountryformaterialisingsupportforthenewlyformedgovernmentofAfghanistanunderthepatronageofTaliban.Russiaisalsoplayingfromthebackhandthroughdesigningacomprehensiveplanofkeepingthesegmentinthehandsofneighbouringstates.SaudifamilieswantedtomaintaintheirdifferencebecauseoftheiralliancewithUSA.Israel,themostactivestateofthatlocality,gotsomebadremarksfromTalibanandwentonfinalizingtokeepdistancefromtheturmoil.TheypeoplealsoreceivedimmediateattentionoftheirChinesecounterpartsforregularizingdevelopmentworks.
Thedualstandofsamegroupofrebelsindifferentsituation raisesaquestionregardingtheirrealobjectivesbehindcurtailingthefreedomofPressandfreedomofwomen.Forwhatpurposetheypeoplewanttosmashthenormalprogressoftheirowncommunitysegment?Thebasicunderstandingdulyinflictedwithanobjectiveofpracticingreligiousandculturalextremismcanputtheentirecommunityintrouble.Normalgrowthoftradeandcommercewillbehalted.Theymayfailtocompetewiththemoderntradepatternoftheworld.Thepowerdulypolarizedintwodifferentsegmentshasforcedtherebelstooptfortheextremismdulyinflictedwithgenderbiasandfalsehood.
ResoluteSupportMission(January2015)launchedbyNATOwasdesignedtoequipAfghanSecurityForcesdifferentlytoequipthemforchallengestocome.ItwasthecommitmenttoaddresstheUNResolution1378[1]thatcompelledUSAtocomeforwardandextendsupportformakingAfghanpeoplefitforthemoderngovernancemechanismwhichissuitableforastateinthemoderncontext.Bytheendof2014theUNSecurityCouncilresolvedanewstandforestablishingpeaceandnormalcyinthecountry.(Resolution2189)[2]
Seriesofdevelopmentwentonacrosstheconflictingsituationinthecountryandthedevelopmentofthemilitarycapabilitiesofthestatewasalsoonitswaythroughincorporationofmodernwarfareequipmentinthebarrackofthenationalarmedforces.Theyalsoreceivedadequatefeedbackandtrainingfromthepeacekeepersregardingtheireffortsofsafeguardingpeopleasawhole.TheyalsogotadequatetechnicalinputfromtheirUScounterpartsregardingproperandtimelyusesofmodernarm-equipment. Theyalsogotanideatotacklerebelsquiteefficiently.OntheotherhandUSledpeacekeepershadtocomeacrossaresolutionforrecognizingthepresenceofTalibanintheregularlineofnationalsecurity.[3] BytheendofApril2020allpoliticalpartiesofAfghanistanwererequestedtomoveforwardbycastingofftheirminutedifferencesfortheformationofaninclusivegovernment.Intra-AfghanpeaceeffortwasonitsnormalwayduringSeptember2020.Ultimatelythedaycame(14thApril2021)todeclareastandofthepeacekeepingforcestoquitthelandaftertransferringthepowerinthehandsofaninclusivegovernment.NATOtookanotherfourmonthstowindupcompletelyfromthelandofconflict.TheredevelopedaconcernforappealingtheNATOpartnersforreconsideringtheirstandinthecontextofthechangingscenario.TheywantedNATOandUnitedNationstore-definetheirroleinAfghanistanforprotectingnativeofthecountryandformediatingasofttransferofpower.ButthecommitmentofNATOforcetoleavethelandbeforeSeptember2021wasconfirmed.
RetentionofExtremism
ExtremismofreligiousandculturaltypehasbecomearealityofAfghanistan.Underwatercurrentofwishesandwillingnessofrebelsandoppressorsareperceivableonthesurface.TheypeoplestartedimplementingtheirtwentyyearlongplantorestorethestateofIslamicEmirateinAfghanistan.BackhistoryofTalibanmadepeopleworry